Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Wedneday 032608, 11 miles, (3, 8)

AM - got out early for the morning 3 mile wake up. Felt good. No abdominal pain, which was nice. Hamstrings did not feel tight, but ankles were cranky. Chalked it up to morning creakiness.

Later AM - biked into the office easy, 41 minutes

Mid day - Pinged DB and KP (at 38 yo, did a 2:29 in the '04 Marathon Trials) the last minute and found out they were heading to the track and decided to join them. KP was doing 800s in prep for Boston and DB was doing 1000s as part of a longer build up. I jogged over to the track and I decided I'd take a crack at the MAF test. After 1 mile at 8:10, I bagged it and did 10 x 200 (w/200 jog). I tried to stride out the 200s but I felt like I could not get any lift. My hamstrings were tight, and just felt heavy. I feel like I was running with a bag of sand on my back. I could not get any lift. I was moving stuff, but I was not moving anywhere. Like I had a backpack on my back or something. There was a bit of a breeze out of the south, but nothing to really effect me that much. I decided that while the 200s were a couple of seconds (or more) slower than what I was doing a month ago, I just could not get uptight about that. I will get back at it.

I have to give up on the MAF training as an exclusive exercise at this point. Arguably, folks will point out that I did not give it a long window to work with, and that even in that window, I cheated some. But I am not seeing an increase in my pace at MAF paces, and if anything, I am getting slower. I will do this experiment again at some point in the future, but it will be a time when I feel I can be more focused on it, more exclusive and less concerned about shorter term results.

This is not saying MAF does not work. It is not saying that it does. It is saying that I don't feel it will maximize training for me right now. That is subjective belief on my part. Objectively ... well, the jury is still out on that. There are definitely those who buy into this theory and those that do not. I have a concern that this will can be interpretted as me saying I don't subscribe to a particular person's training or their coaching philosophy. On the contrary, if what you and your coach (if you have one) are doing is working for you, then keep doing it. I'd prefer these training methodology conversations to be that - conversations. I am not sure anyone has the right answers for all runners yet, and so religious prescription for all runners is probably a recipie for success for some, but disaster for others.

I was going to bike home but TZ met me at the office and we went and got dinner together as a treat. I was a bit tempted to get more running in today to get my weekly mileage back for what I lost on the days off on Sunday and Monday, but that is just silly talk. More running might be good, but not so much for that purpose.

7 comments:

  1. whether MAF works (for you) or not is debatable and will continue to be debated... for sure. I think what is more important is having a training plan that you truly believe in and will stick to wholeheartedly. I don't see where the motivation would come from to get out the door and run miles on end if in the back of your mind you didn't BELIEVE it would help you. I know I couldn't do it.

    do whatcha gotta do... and have fun doing it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. alright, i won't resort to name calling. it is fair to say that you don't think that MAF is working for you but just for fun, i think that you should do a MAF test in a couple of weeks and see what happens - does your aerobic fitness improve or not? also, just out of curiosity, how do your times compare from 5k to a road marathon or half. is there any drop off? also, i notice you do lots of short runs, do you ever do 1:45 to 2+ hour runs...just wondering if the short runs are too short to benefit from MAF....hmmmmmm....

    ReplyDelete
  3. You can call me names! I can take that! :)

    I do long runs (2 hrs) but I have not done a ton as of late due to 2 reasons 1.) my "life" schedule has not been as tolerant of it as of late ... 2.) this groin thing I am dealing with has made that difficult.

    Yeah, I could take some heat over the first reason, but I know you can relate being a working parent. The second however is less a reason of discipline than the first ... the longer I have been going as of late, the more I am aggrevating this thing.

    Again, I am not anti-MAF training. In fact, I think it makes sense for probably 85 percent of training I am doing right now. I just think that the exclusivity of this training is not working for me.

    You raise a good question that I would have to defer to Lucho / CV on - do runs have to be of a minimal time length to effectively develop the aerobic system? I would think that there is some lower limit, of course, but I am doing enough hour length runs to work that system. I did check to see what Mark Allen was doing in his patience phase and a lot of his runs were 30 minutes in length. Of course, that might not be a fair comparasion since he was also doing a lot of biking and swimming in those weeks of base building.

    Finally, to what James said ... and this is a bit more subjective and so open to name calling and mockery ... you got to enjoy it. Yes, I can hear folks say they enjoy building this aerobic base so they can rip later in the year. But I like to "go" every once in a while now (I'd like it more if it felt like my stomach was not going to fall out when I did that).

    I will do a MAF test in a few weeks for fun and to continue moving the conversation forward.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'll chime in - I do have strong leanings as you can see in my blog. However... I also believe that not every approach works for every runner - one size doesn't fit all. And I wholeheartedly agree that you have to believe in your training approach (I wrote on that critical aspect before) and finally YES you should be enjoying this as you go! If not... perhaps you're just a masochist. Coach Dean

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm not sure how you dispute Jack Daniels, Arthur Lydiard, Renato Canova, Friel, Ferrari, Carmichael.. and the millions of other hours of research that have gone in to base training theory.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am up in South Park ... just south of Breckenridge over Hoosier Pass.

    ReplyDelete