Friday, September 26, 2008

Some thoughts on training, Hudson's book

I got some good feedback from Lucho yesterday regarding the strides I did on Wednesday.  Nearly since the moment I met Lucho (almost a year ago), we have been discussing the concept of MAF training.  I had not really heard about it before meeting Tim and I am still learning about it.  My initial basic understanding of this training approach was that it a.) required significant (moderately high) volume b.) required heart rate was not to exceed a prescribed number (typically 145-150) ever  in this period c.) required the period to last until gains (as measured as increases at velocity at the same HR in equivalent tests) began to diminish. 

I had issue with the "exclusivity" of low HR training in the entire period but based on the comments of Lucho from yesterday, that exclusivity may have been a misinterpretation on my part.

In any case, I do agree with Tim, and what I am reading from Hudson's text that a strong aerobic base is required for success in endurance events (5K to marathon) and a key principle to achieving that success is via consistent moderate volume of training of easy running.

That said, I was hearing 25 years ago this tenant of training as well ... "long slow distance makes you a long slow runner."  Now, I understand that this is not an absolute-ism.  Running long and slow can make you the fastest runner on certain days.  Probably most of us could run 25 miles in 4 hours ... which most of us would consider pretty slow ... but how many of us could do a 100 miles in 16 hours?  And so a balance is needed in training.

And this is where I have been enjoying Hudson's text.  His approach seems as common-sense based to me as understanding of current science.  He advocates moderately high miles to support aerobic development, nonlinear periodization (meaning there are no exclusive phases or periods as there were in some traditional programs ... TG used to call this "multi-phasic development") while considering a three phase approach over a progression of training (from general to increasingly more race specific), lots of hills, making your hard days really really hard but your easy days easy, workouts at a variety of paces including various threshold paces and consistent variation and a rest day a week.

Underlying this is not only the thought that race specific endurance is dependent on aerobic development but neuromuscular development.  It is the right mix of the aerobic development (obtained with long runs, easy runs, miles making champions, trial of miles, miles of trials, aerobic support runs, progression runs, ) but also faster paced work (I hesitate to use the word speed work because that seems to fire folks up into thinking that means pure sprints) consisting of intervals, hills, strides, drills, explosive work to increase stride power.

Ineffective development of either end of the spectrum and you are screwed.  We have all seen the kid who starts the 5K race at 65 second quarter pace and then blows up.  They have wheels (neuromuscular strength) but no aerobic engine.  They become victim to this weakness.  We are less likely to see it, but we have all heard the stories of folks who just could not go any faster in a race.  "I couldn't really dig."  I suspect they are victims of a weakness where they have developed an aerobic engine that is then held hostage to a weaker neuromuscular system.

Effective development of both ... driving towards race specific endurance is key to success.  The right mix is dependent on the race, your strengths, weaknesses, what training you are in, your history, etc.

Personally, I see the need to develop both for myself right now.   I am looking to further develop my aerobic system with additional long runs, and a general increase in mileage.  But a focus on hill running almost to the exclusion of other "faster" running has had come at a cost.  I can run up hills more effectively than I could three years ago, but overall I have lost general speed strength. 

This is a tough thing to describe.  I am asked - "why do you need 4:40 mile speed if you are running the last three miles of Pikes in 45 -50 minutes?"  A simple answer is I don't.  A more thoughtful answer is that my ability to run 45 minutes for the last three miles (instead of 57 minutes) comes with a combination of aerobic running (miles), hill running, runs at altitude (after all, that section is above 12000 feet!), and neuromuscular power.  If my best mile I can muster is only a 5:30, then my ability to run 15 minutes a mile is more compromised than if I can run a 4:40.

For what it is worth, Hudson's principles of aerobic development and nueromuscular development seem to match well with Carpenter's suggested triangle of quantity and quality (and rest).  More on that model later.

More to come on this.  And ... I openly welcome challenges to this thinking because it is an organic process for me. 

Oh yeah ... another principle Hudson mentions is that training, while general for all humans needs to be individualized for each human.

9 comments:

  1. "why do you need 4:40 mile speed if you are running the last three miles of Pikes in 45 -50 minutes?"

    Well, due to the altitude and incline at that point of the race, your heart rate and physical exertion level are pretty much like a 5k race pace at that point.

    I think thats what killed me this year - I had done no speed workouts (I had other excuses like having skipped 2 months of running in the spring because of my knee), so I had no top end whatsoever.

    At that altitude and incline you're pretty much maxxing out your heart rate to keep a reasonable pace, and my body was not used to that at all.

    ReplyDelete
  2. GZ- There's possibly the biggest misunderstanding with the MAF principle.. "long and slow miles make long slow runners". That statement is based on PACE PER MILE where MAF is not... MAF is based on HR. If an athlete (and you have watched ME do this!) starts out running at HR 145-155 and it is ~7:00 pace, over time as he gets fitter, that PACE at that HR gets faster. The pace continues to drop as you get more fit... my MAF pace per mile is <5:40 pace! I think long slow miles is bull crap and no one interested in getting fast should do them. I've said this exact same thing to you probably 20 times. With Hudson's book you have finally found a person that will tell you what you want to hear ;) And just to put this on the record once again... I think long slow miles is bull crap and no one interested in getting fast should do them. MAF principles have absolutely nothing to do with long slow miles. If that was true, then you are quite simply stating that my own training has left me slow.
    What I see in you- and this is based 100% on what I have seen you do- the only thing holding you back is a weak aerobic system. I see it when I run with you. I hear when you tell me your HR vs. pace numbers (I've looked at hundreds of workouts based on HR vs. pace with 50 different runners). This advice is not cookie cutter, by the book, and it certainly is not what you want to hear, which is why you fight it. What I am saying is that because you have a weak foundation, you have nothing to build speed on to. If your aerobic pace per mile is 7:30, how can you hold 5:30 for any period of time? You think it needs to go the other way around, build speed first.. there's not a coach on the planet that would agree with that.
    Sorry to be so harsh. If it'll make you feel better I got ripped this morning by Bob after my workout.. he very directly and bluntly told me what my weakness is. But there's no way I can improve as a runner (or a person) until you, Bob, my wife... everyone, is honest.

    ReplyDelete
  3. First and foremost ... I welcome your feedback Lucho. Maybe I "fight" it but nothing good comes easy.

    I agree that I need to work on my aerobic foundation. Hence, a primary part of my training approach is increasing my mileage. The bulk of my training will be focused on easy to moderate runs. Moderate runs will be progression runs or aerobic support runs. I don't see me doing more than two of these a week.

    As I have begun to feel some of the adaptations to mileage I am slightly also looking to increase the quality of those runs. So three weeks ago, it was 90 plus miles just to get those miles. Now, I'd like to get those miles with a little more quality in the form of progression runs and moderate runs like yesterday.

    I might have overdone it a bit yesterday though. I will admit that.

    This primary focus ought to continue to develop my aerobic system. Would you agree with that?

    Additionally, I am looking to do some work that begins capture back some of the neuromuscular strength I had. This will come in the form of the strides (I like your idea of the cross field strides), drills. I am not looking to go to the track and rip 10 x 400.

    I guess when folks talk LSD, I realize they are not talking MAF. I get that. My point is that if I just go around and run 7:30s all the time, then I won't expect to run 5:30's in a 10k. I should not expect to run 5:30's in a 10K when the bulk of my training over the last two years has been 10 minute (or slower!) miles up 10 percent grades. I get that the diff here is the focus on HR and pace ... not just pace.

    Not looking to make an argument, but there are coaches that do advocate speed first. I am not sure I agree with that approach ... at least not for me at this point in my ... "career."

    So what did Bob tell you?

    Stop apologizing for being harsh. You are moving the conversation forward. I know that if you did not give a crap you would not post.

    I am interested also in hearing, maybe in a post you do, specifically what you disagree with Hudson on.

    ReplyDelete
  4. i just wanted to comment on the comments. I love the dialog... a lot of good info especially because I am reading Hudson's book as well, and will be focusing on my run this winter. reading your blogs is like a crash course for me. you guys keep it up

    ReplyDelete
  5. Aww, come on JW ... give an opinion. If you are reading Hudson's book, weigh in on that for this virtual book club.

    Part of the reason why I started blogging my training was to open it up to criticism. There are other reasons as well of course. So I welcome Lucho's self described harshness. I might be slow on the uptake from his perspective, but I still am listening. Of course, I welcome your feedback too.

    Brett - I need to think about what you said before I do a full response ... but I am guessing that a good number of folks have their heart rate tank (drop) at the higher elevations at Pikes. My guess is that they have exhausted themselves at the lower stuff, and with the continual drop in available 02, the body (central gov) begins to shut things down.

    ReplyDelete
  6. G- I really do think you're doing great and I think your approach is just another way to skin a cat. 90 miles per week will develop your aerobic strength. I would suggest however to strap on the HR monitor just to make sure you are getting the most out of those miles at first.You may not be running hard enough on some of your runs! Once you develop your aerobic system the HR monitor can keep you more honest. I have also said in the past that MAF HR may not work for all runners, some it will. Ideally you would be training at ~20 beats below lactate threshold for much of your miles... this may or may not fall in the MAF range. The biggest flaw in the MAF concept is that it doesn't take in to account the individual's aerobic profile. It is a good starting point though if you aren't dialed in on LTHR.
    Part of why I beat my head against the wall is that I see that you can be better.
    My run this morning was with out doubt- the most educational experience I've ever had in a workout. I was very open in my thinking going in and because I allowed myself to examine my weaknesses with honesty.. it all became quite clear. I was prodded on by Bob who is very insightful and can read another runner quite well. Once he helped me to see how I perceive my own running- it immediately became clear where I fall short in races. I ran a race simulation with legs that have run 200+ miles in the last 11 days. Anyway- I'll write a bit more on my blob.
    I don't disagree with any of Hudson's philosophy.. the guy knows far more than I ever will! For myself- if I follow his schedule after Vegas- I will add in a ~8 week aerobic rebuild. With that said though, I am open to trying tempo runs in my base period just to see if my own philosophy holds true. In order for me to learn I need to experience different methodology.
    T

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thats a good point GZ (but I am guessing that a good number of folks have their heart rate tank (drop) at the higher elevations at Pikes. My guess is that they have exhausted themselves at the lower stuff)

    My brother said in 2007 that he could not get his heart rate up the last 3 miles because his calves were so shot.

    I was not physically shot this year, but my body could not handle a high heart rate for any period of time.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Brett - right! I suspect that a good number of folks can't get a high heart rate because they muscularly fail - like in the calves.

    I also think some people can't get a high HR - and by high I mean above 150 - so not really high on the upper stretches simply because they CAN'T run with that low of air pressure (and hence less access to 02 on that grade).

    But I think there is a third case ... maybe one that Lucho can make some analogies on from Ironman. Maybe its a bonk (they run out of fuel)?

    In any case, Matt C has said the real race starts at the A frame (treeline). Unfortunately for many, their race ends before they get there ...

    ReplyDelete
  9. Tim - as I think about what you posted ... one of the points that sticks out at me is the idea that I may not be running my easy runs hard enough! I know there is definitely some truth to that on some of my runs. After some climbs I find that I can pop and on the down, I can't keep my HR up.

    ReplyDelete