I make no secret that I admire what Matt Carpenter has done as a runner. He is arguably the best mountain runner the US has ever produced. Additionally, he has contributed back to the running community in more ways that I can effectively account for here, with a great deal of that contribution through some medium related to Pikes Peak. One of the contributions, was co-authoring the guide on training for Pikes Peak. The guide is currently out of print (in revision) (but this perhaps has only made folks who don't have it, who want special insight to this race only covet it more!).
Like most training books, it reveals running's dirty little secret - there are no secrets. To run far, you need to train by running far. To run fast, you need to train by running fast. To run far and fast, you need to train by running far and fast. Add hills and altitude to the mix ... you get the picture.
No, good training books and guides rarely reveal any new secrets to training as much as they provide a schema for understanding in how to approach training (training is the secret!). In Matt's book, one of the nuggets he reveals that provides a framework for understanding training is the RCQ^2 triangle. Consider a triangle where R - C and Q (squared) make each of the corners of a training plan.
R is for recovery. You improve not with just training, but with the recovery from your training. If you don't believe this, try to improve by not ever allowing recovery.
C is for consistency. This is consistency in training of actually doing it, and what you do.
Q squared (Q^2) is quantity (long, far, aerobic) and quality (speed, neuromuscular).
It is the effective mix of these in the triangle that lead to success. Focus to much on one (or not enough on an other) and you will create a weakness (that can be exploited). Only go long and slow and you will become long and slow as a runner. Only go short and fast and you won't have the ability to endure over the course of the event. Be inconsistent and you won't have the foundation to build on to meet your highest potential.
I love the simplicity of this schema framework. It seems to have worked well for Matt too.
It's pretty basic. I'm profoundly unmoved by the odd-ball coaches who have such a firm grasp on some other approach. Their firm grasp is actually them holding their throat, choking, and likewise suffocating those they're escorting down that particular road . . . to nowhere.
ReplyDeleteWord.
Well, I think I would say a good coach is someone who can observe what it is that you are doing, and reveal what you ought to be doing within the basic framework. The key to being good is also able to specifically modify it for you. The principles for training are basic. How they are applied to each of us are within them are intricately detailed.
ReplyDeleteAnd so a coach reveals to us the most effective path to success. We really knew that path all along but often put up our own blinders, crutches, roadblocks to getting there.
I am no coach mind you but I am occasionally asked for training advice. The conversation goes something like this (usually)...
THEM: Hey, I ran 55 minutes for the Bolder Boulder 10k last year. What would I need to do to break 50 next year?
ME: Umm, well ... what are you doing now?
THEM: Oh, I run maybe three days a week. 30 minutes each time.
ME: Well, I'd say, run more.
THEM: Well, yeah but what workout could I do? (*this is if they are still around talking to me*)
ME: Run more. Really. That is probably all you need to do when you consider what you are doing and what you want to do.
No, not all conversations are like that. But the theme is the same. There are no real secrets. Train. Train alot. Train for aerobic endurance. Train for speed. Train for race specificity. Mix things up.
I guess I am not equipped to be a coach because my marketing skills would be lacking.
For those that are coaches - please don't take offense at this. The ones that I know of you are good because THEY FOCUS ON THE INDIVIDUAL ... listening, observing, making recommendations. In many regards, they are more a therapist in my mind than a coach.
Yea there are no secrets.
ReplyDeleteBut when you talk about distance, tempo, speed, etc., there are a myriad of approaches within those workouts and a myriad of ways to mix and match them together.
Thats where I see a lot of value in guidance from people with that kind of expertise.
Agree
ReplyDeleteOn coaching...
ReplyDeleteSince Pikes, I've been trying to figure out how I'm going to get to a 2:35 and I've thought about hiring a coach - there are tons of options in Boulder. Another option is to hire P. Vail as a personal pacer for the entire race. Every time I think about it though, I nix the coaching option because I'd get more satisfaction out of self-coaching (and pacing) myself there, even at the risk of never getting there. At the same time, I think it'd be hard for a new coach to know what will work for me, or anyone else, given my (his/her) preferences. I like to run with X, Y, and Z groups and go at the group's pace for those runs. I like to throw in a long trail run when I can, had fun running to/from work yesterday, etc - seems unlikely that a coach could craft all of that into some training plan any differently than I have.
Like Matt said, at it's base level it's a pretty simple formula and like you said, I try to run as much as I can and keep that as my most basic principle. Like Brett said, it's about piecing it all together and for me, that really just comes down to scheduling - a coach can't figure that for me.
GZ,
ReplyDeleteYour comment about non-runners asking about training advice gave me a laugh. One thing that baffles me is when I have co-workers, friends, et al. that sign up for training groups, be it "Team in Training" et al.
Those groups have these non-runners out on the track running 200's, 400's, et al. training for a marathon.
Meanwhile, most of these people can't even run the full 26.2 miles, so my thinking is just make sure you can run the whole way, speed training is not going to help and don't even worry about it.
However, I think a lot of it is psychological. People who join those groups like the controlled environment of a track and the coaching that goes along with it and a track is a controllable environment where people think it's the only way to get faster.
Justin - I am thinking sub 2:30 so we can just coach each other with ridicule, sarcasm, and beating the shit out of each other each Sunday.
ReplyDelete(speaking of which, I am not sure I will be there this Sunday).
Seriously, I did 2:37 when I was in like 16:45 shape ... 2:48 in the snow this year when I was in 17;45 shape. I realize results will vary based on strengths, etc.
RunColo (hey good luck this weekend) In regards to a coach, there are some folks that just get the benefit of having a coach regardless of what they tell them. Just playing someone to tell you what to do ... it keeps you honest. I certainly can relate to that. I use this principle in a slightly different way though ... I try to run with people and I use this blog to keep me honest. I know no one gives a crap if I train or not but the fact that I make myself broadcast it is one of many factors that keeps me disciplined. It is an internal coaching mechanism if you will.
Sub 2:30, 2:37, etc - I was talking about a road marathon for my 2:35, not PP ascent. Although I think the goal for PP ascent likely will be 2:35ish also (with a 1:25 descent).
ReplyDeleteI too will not be there on Sunday as I am watching Run Colo and the FF team in action on Sunday.
GZ,
ReplyDeleteregardless of the individual a good coach still addresses those "principles" with an approach that consists of specifics. Run easy, run hard, recover, rest, yada yada. Do 2 a days, train for this race, sit in a sauna, use this stretch tool . . .
specifics. That's the key. Consistency is taken for granted.
Agree. I don't want this to come across as anti-coach. Good coaches are obviously key to the success of many great athletes. They have the ability to see the path for the athlete that the athlete has trouble seeing. I can't see the middle of my back the way someone else can.
ReplyDeleteJustin raises a good point - a person has to be open to a coach to be coach-able. If you already have ideas as to how you want to train, and are not willing to defer to a coach - don't bother.
I guess my original point was that training principles, while they have matured in the last 30 years, are not hugely different for endurance training. Yeah, we know a lot more about V02, nutrition, etc ... but for the everyday joe and the elite ... the same basic principles apply, regardless if you are being coached or not.
As a total side note, I am here in Chautauqua Park and there are guys playing kickball. In the middle of the field is a keg. Every guy has a beer in their hand. A guy just got thrown out at home as he was running there. His beer went everywhere. Now that looks to be a fun game. I don't see a coach though.
My first comment was pretty anti-coach. I agree with you. To date my best running (not real impressive but my best nonetheless - 1:30 1/2 marry) was the result of self coaching. I think I've learned a lot this year though I'm afraid that concerns what not to do.
ReplyDeleteHave a good one.
blah blah blah. can we get another post about beer (squared) ? just kidding, good stuff!!! i need to maximize my R to get to C. i usually mix up some Q squared, forget enough r, and C is sacrificed.
ReplyDeleteanyhow, YOU seem to be pretty much a consistency master (aside from that thing that i still remember that is not to be names)...and that will pay off for sure.
this post makes no sense. i guess i need more beer. or a bigger brain.
first things first... I want to find a kickball game like that!
ReplyDeletenow... about coaching. I have been both coached and coached myself and had success with both. I have worked with 3 different coaches for parts of the last 3 seasons and learned a lot from them and been able to apply it to my own training when coaching myself.
With that being said I really do like coaching myself, making my own schedule, but I have a tendency to over think things, and maybe overtrain a bit (there I admitted it!).
I agree with a lot of what Mock said about why a coach would not work for him. The same things apply to me (and most people). Lucky for me the coach I am working with now knows me very well. I have spent the last 3 years chasing him around races courses, training with him, and picking his brain.
When I decided that I wanted to have somebody guide at the end of this season he was an obvious choice. He definitely knows me, knows my strengths and weaknesses, and knows what it will take to get me where I need to be. he's also a good friend so I dont feel (too) bad when I have to ask him to change my schedule up a bit when life/work gets in the way.
It's definitely very rare to find a coach like this especially if you have been competing/racing/training for a long time on your own.
I am really enjoying being coached right now because I don't have to think about things... i just train. That's only because I have 100% trust in my coach right now, which is rare. In the past when being coached I would question everything and wonder if I was really doing the right things for me. In retrospect, sometimes I was, but there were also times when I think I wasn't being pushed enough or spending enough time on my weaknesses.
The bottom line is coaching can be good if you can find a good coach that will take the time to get to know you, know your past, and really understand your goals and limiters. Cookie cutter plans and workouts are bogus. The most important thing though is that you trust the coach you are working with wholeheartedly and aren't afraid to ask questions.
ok... that's it. enough rambling. Can we talk about beer now?