Tuesday, March 17, 2009

METS info

  • On the PPMB - I have been enjoying this thread: 
    • From Rick:  Looking for some input on what to make of 2 slightly different Tempo runs done on the treadmill. 1) 30 min. 5mph @ 12% grade is 2.5 miles and 1584' of climbing. 2) 30 min. 6mph @ 10% grade is 3 miles and (the same) 1584' of climbing. It's easier for me to do the 5mph @ 12% grade. Can one draw any conclusion as to what this might indicate? What strenghts/weaknesses this has exposed? Which one is more important to be good at for the PPA? A goal of mine would be to do 6mph @ 12% in the next few months. Thanks!
    • From Matt Carpenter:  Rick, In my opinion those are not "2 slightly different tempo runs." Those are not even in the same league and the one at 5mph better feel easier. You have a 2 minute per mile difference in pace but only a 2% difference in climbing. If you are trying to find out if you are weaker / stronger at different grades you need to run them at a comparable effort. One formula to do this is METS. Metabolic output. My treadmill has it built in which I use to compare different grades/paces. Here is what it says about your 2 workouts: 5mph (12 min mile) @12% is 12.7 6mph (10 min mile) @10% is 14.2 So again, you are working way harder on the second one so no wonder it feels harder. The pace you should run at 12% to get an approximate equivalent is 5.6 mph (10:43 min per mile) which according to my treadmill is a 14.1. Then you would be comparing apples to apples. Also, I would spread the grade apart more perhaps using 10% and 15% so get a better feel for which you are stronger at. Finally, to help better to prepare you for Pikes be sure and suck the air out of the room before you start;-) MC
    • I asked:  Interesting. I can't seem to land exactly on what the best way to calculate METS is if your mill does not calculate it. What I gather however is that it would be your caloric output per hour (which most treadmills have) divided by your weight. That sound right to you?
    • Matt responded:  Here is what my treadmill's manual says about EST METS: Displays 1.0 when treadmill belt is stopped to indicate resting metabolic level. Displays METS, derived from speed and grade, when belt is running. Uses formulas in Appendix F of ACSM "Guidelines for Graded Exercise Testing and Exercise Prescription." When STOP EXER is pressed, displays the highest MET level achieved during exercise (up to but not including the last 15 seconds before STOP EXER was pressed). I am guessing that one can find the formula out there somewhere. But I do find that using the METS allows me to select different speed/grade combinations to end up with ~equivalent exertion levels. So as an example, if I was thinking of doing say 6mph (10 min per mile) at 15% grade but my Achilles was acting up (as just a random example) I would be smart not to be doing 15% grade. So instead, I might cut that back to 7.5% and use the METS indicator to see that 7.5 mph (8 min per mile) is about the same workout but does not put near as much stress on my Achilles. Of course, there would be some adjustment as I may be more or less efficient at hills vs flats than the formulas account for but it gives me a good starting place. There are also formulas for Est Calories/min and Est VO2 and my treadmill displays them both as well. Both are based on METS however so I just stick with the METS. According to my manual, VO2 EST = 3.5 X METS and EST Cal/min = VO2 (ml/kg x min) x weight (kg) x 0.005 Cal/ml. I just put in my weight and it does the rest. But I am *guessing* that if your treadmill has a Calories/min display it could be used as the same function as I us METS. And no matter, one could also figure out different speed/grade combinations just by using a heart rate monitor. The only thing there is then one does not know how far off they are from the "formulas" to have some indication if they should be working on hills more than flats or flats more than hills. But you can tell that by if people you run with often leave you on the hills or you are leave them. Matt
    • Got to love Matt and his random example ... :)  I responded ... All great stuff, and thanks for the detail in the answer. Most mills I have seen have a cals per hour. Usually, they ask you to enter your wt and or age, and then they are doing something to determine that cal per hour. Back to Rick's question, if a mill does not calculate METS, I think (as you also stated) that number could be used as a relative measure of effort when manipulating speeds versus grades. HR, of course as you say, is a much better indicator, and probably revealing of weaknesses, strengths. I might do some calculations the next time I am on the mill (more brain playing ... just to break up the mill stuff). When I am moving fairly well on the mill, say six minute pace on a flat I am seeing cal/hr numbers north of a 1000 (which seems to make sense if you go with the rule of thumb of 100 cals per flat mile). If I weigh 140 during that run, my MET rate would be 7.1. Now I need to see how the caloric numbers shift at different grades. Thanks again Matt.
    • John Garner - To quickly calculate the METS of a given speed/incline, you can use the calculator at : http://www.exrx.net/Calculators/WalkRunMETs.html Note that METS is independent of your weight or time, so all you need to enter on the form above is speed, grade and walking vs running. The calculator also shows the resulting VO2 required for that particular speed/grade (which is by definition METS x 3.5) Now, all of that said, there appears to be a boundary issue: According to the ACSM's METS calculator, running 3.5mph up a 15% grade is 'easier' than walking at the same pace/grade. My HR would indicate just the opposite. So my theory is that there is a biomechanical gotcha somewhere in there. I've noticed (pure observation here) during the incline club runs that taller folks tend to start walking sooner than shorter folks at a given speed/grade. (I'm 6'4") So there may be a mechanical (dis)advantage for those with longer legs when it comes to running vs walking up an incline. But as any researcher would indicate, this is a question for a future project :-)
  • 2 comments:

    1. In reading over the latest comments, I agree with the 'crossover point' on walking vs. running. At slower speeds (he referenced 3.5 mph) walking gives me like 10 bpm lower result than if I were jogging. At some point (based on % incline and pace) I just can't efficiently walk that fast...and its better to run.

      I bet my HR is still lower at any pace if walking, so long as I can actually do it.

      ReplyDelete
    2. I'd like to think that hypothetically you could walk fast enough to just keep drilling the HR up ... but I agree with your observation ... I have wondered if this is because the cadence of walking is so much lower and less impactful that the HR will not just go up that high. I have wondered if the big muscles of the leg and butt actually do some of the driving of the HR versus the opposite ...

      ReplyDelete