Sunday, September 6, 2009

Sunday 090609

  • Tim Parr has posted some unofficial WMRC results. Word is that women's team took the bronze. Nancy H has also posted this.  Looks to be solid results from the teams around the board.
  • 11 miles, easy. I am dealing with a bunch of "niggles." My right leg is got some wierdness from the car smack, my groin is groaning as of late, and I have had a wierd bulge in my right quad since the PPM weekend bike crash. Going easy is best for me right now. AHR = 137.
  • Week in review.  81 miles on week, a little more than 11.5 hours.  67 miles on September, about 9.5 hours. 2432 miles on the year, 21557 minutes

9 comments:

  1. Twitter feed has some up too. Women - bronze.

    Just as Parr won Cheyenne Canon and was the last US placer, so was Megan Lund who also won Cheyenne Canon. Parr is an anomaly with his schedule and Lund could have something too, but seeing that doesn't really support their claim that having the selection race on a course similar to the world course would pick the best team. In other words, could've had the selection race at Barr Trail and picked a team just as well.

    I doubt anyone would've picked Benford to be our top finisher.

    Just as Parr likely suffered from a long season (he is on the Imogene start list also - I'll have predictions up next week), I wonder if it's the same with Gates too. I think he's placed well back in the US pack the last two years now. Just as many have speculated that Parr was not doing all he could to do his best at worlds by racing Leadville, should we give Gates the same treatment with biking all over Europe pre-race? I'm on the "it's their choice, they earned the right" side, just throwing that out there though.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Justin

    Good stuff.

    After the long comment thread on the mountainrunning blog, I personally concluded that there is not a perfect solution - that there will be some compromise.

    That said, I agree: having a course that is very similar to the WM course is not necessary. Certainly, up and down is probably necessary on up and down years, and just up on up years is probably best - but I feel that making courses emulate the world course is over-emphasized. I feel that the best athletes will qualify anyway - regardless of the course. I feel it would be better to pick races that further establish the sport. FWIW - we do this in the OT marathon. Boston and NY do not emulate the race conditions in Beijing (weather or course profilewise)- and nobody really was concerned about that.

    There is a whole other conversation on the number of races, etc. And while I started thinking that multiple races were better ... I think the point on the length of the season is valid - and we probably ought to move to a singular race.

    Finally, if we are going to be serious about sending our best team, then there probably needs to be some "flak" about throwing in too many races in the mix. What Parr and Gates did is epic - and something I love to do, but it is fair to ask if that is what was best for this race. If Ritz decided to do a marathon the week before the 10k at Beijing, people would flip - even if it was their right and they earned the trip.

    ... but this is mountain running ... not the Olympics ... so there is ying and yang to that.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Got to disagree with you here. I think that finding courses similar to the world championship courses is very important in the selection process. Championship courses are very different to about anything you find here in the states. I think the exposure the selection courses gives to runners has been a great benefit to the runners that have made the team in the last few years as well as those who hope to in the future.
    The fact that Benford was our top finisher demonstrates this and Tim Parr placing as well as he did coming off of Leadville backs it up as well. Tim has run on the team a couple other times and finished in similar placing.

    I have nothing against the bigger established races, but I see no benefit in using them for selection.

    As I recall the OT marathons were held in NYC and Boston but both were vastly different than the established marathon races.

    I can't wait to hear more reports from the worlds.

    -Andy

    ReplyDelete
  4. Don't want to repeat that thread on Buzz's blog, but...

    Andy,

    Flip it around and look at the women's side - Erholtz and Lundy were the top US finishers at Worlds and both were well off the pace at Cheyenne Canon, the race that was supposed to emulate the Worlds course.

    All of the course talk was, and is again, about Cheyenne Canon, so what about Cranmore - was that course altered this year to emulate the Worlds course or did they leave it alone and leave it as a selection race just to have a race in the east?

    I'm totally with GZ that if they had used Barr Trail as the selection race instead of Cheyenne Canon, we'd have the same folks on the team and would've brought some more visibility to mountain running. Of course others would have ran Barr Trail then, but most likely Erholtz and Kimmel both still would've made the team on the women's side. Hard to believe that Parr wouldn't have made the team still too.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think what's been alluded to about Parr's and Ricky's epic seasons - it will be hard to tell how well the qualifying races are at determining the team until we actually see these guys on the US Team try and peak for the Worlds. The women are Bronnz twice now, right? Do they seem to be peaking in early September?

    ReplyDelete
  6. What the hell is going on down there with these guys in Gunnison?

    Duncan won the Grand Teton 50 today?!?

    Gone are the days when Bernie's race schedule was considered the epic standard.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Beth - thanks. Me too!

    Andy (assuming this is Andy A who has been on teams previously and is a FF team mate of mine).

    First and last - I will defer to the judgement of folks like you, Paul L, and Nancy who have been in the sport longer than me, are more knowledgeable and are giving back to it. I sometimes feel that by asking questions, I am being a bit of an a%*hole - because those folks are putting in time and energy. Who am I to ask these sorts of questions?

    That said, I do feel as a fan and as a participant, I can ask some questions. The responses have been good.

    When Cheyenne Canyon was set up, I was left wondering why we had to set up a separate race. I was informed (via the mountainrunning blog) that it was because it was to emulate the course conditions in Europe.

    As a part of that conversation, I saw that there were other topics with course and team selection that were a bit contraversial - that I had not really thought of before. One selection race or many? Races at altitude or not? An at large berth given or not? Existing races or not? Ultimately, the paths that had been chosen were an outcome of the sports leaders trying to compromise to please as many of the constituents as possible.

    My thinking has changed on the number of races (from thinking multiple was better to one).

    Ideally, you want to "prep" race under the conditions MOST like your "actual" race. Obviously this is difficult. My take is that we over-emphasize this aspect of the race setup and that is in turn a detriment to the sport. It means we potentially create other races that are poorly attended, not well known in the public, and potentially further spread the athletes out.

    What do I mean by spread the athletes out? Well - take Rickey G for example ... he races Mount Washington, breaks and hour and goes into the history books. But it leaves him tapped for Cranmore the next week. Ernholtz wins BTMR but can't pull together a placing in Cheyenne Canyon shortly there after.

    I know the return argument is that if it is important for those racers to be on the team, they will skip those other races and focus on making the team.

    There is certainly some truth in that but I think we benefit more and we promote the sport more when we leverage the classic races and get potentially new excited folks (read - younger talent) when someone breaks an hour at MW. Who is the next young man that will break an hour? Maybe he was sitting on the sideline at the 22% grade wall?

    And I also think that if you line up Rickey, Joe, Zac, Tim, Matt, etc, etc up in a field on a course that is well established in the public eye, but less than well engineered to emulate course conditions for the WMRC you are going to get the same team anyway. Certainly up down years need an up down component (so MW as the selection this year would be out), but an up down race does not have to be (IMO) three laps of up and down to be right. The same cream will rise to the top if it is 1 lap of up and down, or 10 at some point.

    Will there be corner case exceptions? Absolutely. There will be the guy or gal who could have made the team if the course was more like the one in Europe. But that is true on a variety of fronts ... there will be somebody who does not make the team because they show up with a cold.

    Again, I appreciate your input, and respectfully appreciate the decisions of folks like Nancy, Paul, etc.

    Hope to run with you soon

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey George, yeah it is me, Andy A.
    Just to explain the reasoning as I see it behind the selection a little better..
    I agree with you that you would have some of the same people up front no matter what kind of course you picked. I'm sure if you lined all the same people up you could probably pick the US 5 or 10 k team at the half marathon championships. I think picking a race like Barr Trail would actually hurt US mountain running. I've only heard good things about the race and think it might make a good trail championships but it is a far cry from what you tend to see in the European championship type races.
    Creating similar courses gives a lot of exposure to runners they would otherwise miss. Most US runners are shocked by the courses when they first see them. Even some of the best are forced to walk parts!

    Did you see the team report? It sounds like there were some great performances, especially on the women's side. The whole womens team finished within a minute of each other in 10-17th place.

    I'd love to share with you more. What do you have coming up? There are still a lot of good trail races over the next few weeks.

    -Andy

    ReplyDelete
  9. So - while I confess, I am a big fan of the BTMR - I am not specifically advocating that race would be THE selection race. I think it could be a contender for the up down race, but I am not stating that ought to be THE race.

    I saw Kirsch's report. The men's grouping is pretty damn impressive.

    I doubt I am racing soon, and if I do it will be on a whim. I am going to take a bit of a break here with school and soccer starting for the kids - and figure out what I am going to do next.

    Impressive double by you this weekend!!

    ReplyDelete