The crap referred to in this post drives me a little crazy. For some reason, because Meb is not American born, he is in the eyes of some not an American? That just comes across as total horse dung to me.
Analogy here … I am adopted. When this topic would come up as a kid, I’d always feel some discomfort when people would make a distinction between my biological parents versus my adoptive parents. I had parents. There were obviously two people who contributed to the physical creation of my being, but my parents were and are my parents. In fact, they had to go through a lot more crap in becoming my parents, including extensive interviews, background checks, as well as paying for the privilege and burden of being my parents. In my opinion, a helluva lot harder to become parents that way than simply fornicating their way there.
Meb – he chose to become an American citizen. He had to take a test to do it. I’d say a helluva lot harder than just being born here. He was born in a country that was war torn and his family decided to come to a better place – our country. He represented the US in the Olympics (uhh, by the way, the last medal winner before Meb in the marathon – some guy named Frank Shorter – was born in Germany … nobody seems to talk about him not being born here and thus his efforts not counting). He ran HS in California, went to college there, and he chose to wear the USA singlet verus the singlet of his sponsor come race day in NY. He’s not American? To say he is not is about on par as saying my parents are not my parents. In other words, wrong.
Last I checked, a large part of the American story was about coming here …
I hate to say it, but this has everything to do with the color of his skin (perhaps his name contributes to this socially conservative aka racist point-of-view, too). America has been a nation of immigrants from the get go, sure. But, the dominant group has been white, in fact, white Anglo-Saxon of British descent.
ReplyDeleteDespite all the progress, there are still those that embrace what historian George Fredrickson calls the Ethnic Hierarchy "conception of how ethnic or racial groups should relate."
It's a bummer, but at least it's fairly limited.
Well said, brother!
ReplyDeleteI figured this would come up.
ReplyDeleteSpent some time on the Indian reservations last week. They would probably like to speak with Mr. Rovell about the issue of who is and who isn't a "real" American citizen.
Didn't know Shorter was from Germany though.
FYI, the reason I was rooting for Hall more than Meb was because I thought Meb was too old to win. Thought Hall had a much better chance.
IMO its not about his race insofar as just that he's black for the sake of being black...more to rub it in Americans' face that east Africans still rule the endurance running world...and our only chance is if we have a transplant from east Africa come over here and compete with us.
ReplyDeleteI'm sure its largely driven by jealousy. Of course, grab one of those recent 5k and 10k videos of Ritz and see how many east Africans he smoked in those races...
We are catching up to them again and they're scared.
Runners aren't born. Meb didn't have the advantage of running 10 miles each way to school each day for 20 years...he grew up over here. So any argument they try and make is silly.
Shorter was born in Germany, as his father was an Army doc over there. Yeah, so different I guess. But still, I think the entire thing of "American born" is a over-hyped.
ReplyDeleteAnd I totally get rooting for some guy. Meb, with his not making the 08 team ... hell, a lot of folks thought he was done.
And I agree with Fitzgerald on this count: you can bet if Culpepper was in the mix, I'd be cheering for him over the rest of the field because I know the guy.
His skin color may have something to do with this, yet I doubt it is the chief deciding factor. If he looked like Ritz or Hall yet had a French or German or Russian name and accent, he would still be marginalized. Stuff like this is nothing new and it can be found in many species (and no doubt among countless Native Americans, to boot) going way back: xenophobia and entitlement.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1627019,00.html
If someone has a "friend" or a fellow "Californian" (in my case) or fellow Texan/Coloradoan etc. in a race, then such favorable prejudice is justifiable. If Meb had won the San Diego Marathon, he'd perhaps be more embraced around here because he has some San Diego affiliation.
ReplyDeleteBut the reaction referenced in Fitzgerald's article seems more general. And if he looked like Ritz, I think those same "critics" would feel more comfortable. I watched the end of the race without audio and it sure looked like the enthusiasm was fairly subdued during Meb's final kick over those last few miles. He kept pointing to his chest ("U.S.A") and once or twice motioned his arms to encourage more crowd noise. I thought if that was Hall the crowd would have been going nuts, animated, loud.
And part of this reaction does have to do with Meb's diminished presence in the men's field, no?
Anyways, these days when someones says it's not about race or money, or this or that, unfortunately that's exactly what "it's" about.