Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Wednesday 020310

Greg C asks a fair question about Born to Run author McDougal’s investigations … A bit of Chris if you do not know him.  Pete Magill gets into the mix as well with the “Barefoot Professor.” 

Crazy day at work (knew it coming in) and so only got out for a very short stretch.  7 miles easy.  Mentally fried from work, and so while I needed the run to recharge a bit, I was cooked.

Post script – I think I have given this enough play on the blog.  Clearly the whole thing is getting a lot of play in the interwebs.  Short of it for me is this:  however you run, exercise – great.  If barefoot running gets more people moving and exercising -  I am for it.  That said, if you are happy with shoes – amen.

9 comments:

  1. I chimed-in. Crowther's blog (the scientist/outspoken runner) is great.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Why does everyone overlook the most awesome part of that book - Jen Shelton and her drinking? Maybe it's not the barefoot thing that keeps one injury free. It's massive boozing!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Just talked to someone who is out 3 months that was "trying" the barefoot/minimalist thing. No run/no bike/ no hike - 3 months. Blew up his AT. Sorry but my feet like shoes and I'm not embarrassed about it!
    Steve

    ReplyDelete
  4. Greg is right on with his post. Chris's "zest for hyperbole" is exactly what turned me off the most about BTR. Essentially, he tries to have it both ways i.e., write a best-selling, dumbed-down, pop-culture book that the wide-ranging public will readily consume AND still attempt to lend some true academic credibility to his arguments by blithely tossing around a few names and publications. Obviously, his commitment to the former severely undermined any effort at the latter.

    Nevertheless, Chris is a good guy and I completely appreciate his major, over-arching motivation here: get people outside, tuned-in, and RUNNING.

    HOWEVER, it disappoints me that he wrote a book that allows people to ridicule and poke fun at what I believe to be an extremely important basic concept: THE SIMPLEST OPTION IS OFTEN THE BEST (in my opinion, running shoes included).

    I might need to write a more in-depth blog post of my own about all of this sometime soon.

    Tony

    ReplyDelete
  5. Here is what I posted:
    "There are so many problems/omissions in that piece its hard to know where to start (and in statistics, omissions are problems).

    Did you know that the more Churches there are in a city, the more rapes, murders, alcoholics, and drug users you will find? Great! Maybe I should go write a book called Born To Run (away from organized religion).

    But what I didn't tell you (conveniently) is that it is probably only a correlation to population size. In general, the larger the city, the more of -anything-. Convenient omission, no? Did I do my homework? Did I survey those alcoholics, etc. and find out if -they- in particular went to church? You'll never know, because I didn't publish it.

    In running as in anything, sure it makes sense the more of anything you use to protect yourself, the less 'hardened' that something will become. Do you have more calluses on your hands if you don't wear gloves? There are so many questions unanswered.

    How many people would not be running if it were not for being able to wear running shoes? What percentage of people do not wear running shoes? Is it a minuscule data set? Are those people just more careful and in tune with their bodies and taking breaks when appropriate? What is considered an injury after all? Knee tendonitis, shin splints, every day pains? Do shoe wearers and non-shoe wearers answer that question differently? Are barefoot people more proud of what they do and not answer they get injured unless its really bad? How many non-athletes and weekend warriors run barefoot versus those who wear running shoes? Are the shoe wearers able to run in all kinds of rocky/rooty terrain which puts them more at risk of injuries anyway?

    There seems to be such a lack of data it makes the entire premise (or almost the entire premise) useless."

    ReplyDelete
  6. I got two separate questions today from co-workers on my thoughts related to this topic ... one spun into Newton shoes (are those things really 150 bucks?) and one spun into chat on barefoot running. I kept trying to get back to Jen Shelton by asking if folks ever heard of Brownie.

    In any case, I am only wearing the Five Fingers if they custom make them for me as the Four Fingers for my left foot.

    ReplyDelete
  7. i'm with brownie...jen s. is my kind of girl, lol.

    btr is a great "story" yet is pretty simplistic in its presentation of the whole barefoot running thing. as anyone who has ever done any kind of research knows, it is pretty easy to prove something right(rather than disprove it)as you can almost always find research/stats to back up your point of view(which is precisely what chris did...). i'm just suprised that so many inteligent people haven't questioned his sweeping generalizations...my ancestors weren't 'born to run' - they were too busy freezing their asses off. were they going to run down a seal or opt for staying warm and do some ice fishing/harpooning instead? and i won't even get into how he neglected to include women into his "anthropological" conclusions.

    as for the newtons...they work great once you shave them down!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Agree with GZ about sensationalism watering down an otherwise interesting message. Had the fortune to meet "Caballo Blanco" last year, and he was quite warm and outgoing: nowhere near as elusive and mysterious as made out to be in the book.
    (And, he was wearing shoes!)

    I'm glad to see that it's gotten some folks interested in running, but why does it have to come at the expense of logic, rationalism, and the scientific method?

    Also agree with Tony that there are positive aspects of minimalism that might be lost by the sensationalism. Ironically (and similar to yoga, perhaps), the ideas of biomechanics and simple pleasure of running has become a "consumption" of minimalism itself: buy and talk about the book, buy 5-fingered shoes, etc.

    Let's just run!

    ReplyDelete