Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Tuesday 092512

Cold is clearing a bit.  I avoided any sort of cold medicine last night, so I did not sleep as well – but I don’t feel like an oven dried seed of snot this AM.

Saw the elk in Broomfield this AM while getting KZ to school.

Mid day - 9 miles.  Listened to (part of) the latest TalkUltra (episode 18).  There is a solid interview with Dr. Noakes.  Simply put, when Noakes talks in this sport, you probably ought to listen.  Noakes’ latest text “Waterlogged”  challenges a lot of assumptions on the amount of water or sports drink during endurance events, as well as the need to take salts.  Check it out. 

I particularly enjoyed Noakes’ final comments about not being particularly religious or dogmatic with any approach.  As I have listened to his commentary (in this interview and in other interviews the spring, summer), I have had the following questions bubbling in my head:

  • Can someone have a broken central governor? (like if you can hold your breath until you pass out … is that a broken governor?)
  • Salt has no impact to cramps … except it does when salt is applied to the tongue?  What is that about?
  • Isn’t there some need to take some salt to assure appropriate digestion of sugars?  I think I heard something about the pH of the gut being at some appropriate level to absorb water and food.  But that might by hype.

I know you are out there Wes and you will have a take.

Evening – 4 miles with dog Lucy.

Competitor for sale with possibly TdF buying it?  Hmmm …

17 comments:

  1. A) Buy a bottle of S-caps for $14. B) Buy a used copy of Waterlogged on Amazon for $14 and you never have to buy S-caps again!

    ReplyDelete
  2. TdF will probably buy that wildly successful M1le series too.

    ReplyDelete
  3. >Salt has no impact to cramps

    Huh? I'll tell that to my calves the next time I take an S-cap and my cramps disappear. I find it hard to believe that the 4 ounces of water I washed it down with cured them.

    Until last year I would have thought elk in Broomfield was crazy talk, then I saw a pair last summer in the middle of suburban Lakewood, far from the mountains: http://tinyurl.com/bm4u3jc. If they have a greenbelt, they will travel.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Remember that Noakes says in the talk ultra interview and in the book that "there is no evidence" that ingestion of supplemental salt has any effect on cramping. The book illustrates exactly how thin any evidence is. But, there appears to be a neuromuscular interaction with the taste of salt that has some affect on cramping. Bottom line: we just do not know what is going on and, with the exception of some individuals with certain health issues, there is no adverse consequence to taking supplemental salt- so when in doubt....

    There is even less evidence to support a digestive effect, but this not to say that salt is not important to support absorption/digestion during racing- only that there is little clear evidence that it does. Much work to be done on this subject.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think the concept of "a" central governor is largely overblown and oversimplified and not really a useful model for results-based training (I've been thinking about this for awhile and never wrote out the big post that's in my head), or at least I don't see what it yields that's novel with regard to training approach. The point of the theory (borrowed from decades earlier) was a contrast to the idea of muscle or energy systems being the absolute limiting factor in performance. We've seen this isn't true -- it appears the brain regulates/limits performance to prevent this. Mostly.

    A "broken" central governor is a great question, George, because it highlights the limits of the theory -- or at least the oversimplified way that people are trying to apply it as one "thing" in the brain that's holding us all back from remarkable performances. See "Criticisms" from the wiki page...but off the top of your head, you're probably familiar with the epic women's 1997 Ironman crawl or Brian Morrison's controversial WS finish. Clearly, it is not unheard of for people to run at the absolute extreme of what their muscles are capable of.
    As for your breathing question: central sleep apnea and SIDS are attributed to broken hypoxic responses.
    How about Diane Van Deren? A lobectomy changes her perception of time and need for sleep -- which she has found advantageous in running ultra distances.
    Other mental disorders and drugs can affect various parts of the nervous system that would otherwise be important in "governing" performance (e.g. pain sensation).

    My summary? The brain indeed does prevent voluntary exercise performance in most people to the extreme of causing DEATH. No surprise -- sounds like a great script for evolution to me. But this is a combination of multiple inputs throughout the body (see the examples above), all of them trained at the same time that musculoskeletal, cardiovascular, and energy systems are trained as well. There's no "one thing" to train or to trick. Any governing of performance is still correlated of your absolute ability from training (which does in itself already include dealing with perceptions of pain), so I don't see much use in the central governor as a training model other than using it as a mantra to remind yourself that you're not going to die. Nobody is going to "think" themselves into a 2-hour marathon.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I should clarify my bluntness: the main point of the Central Governor Theory, I think, is that performance is both ability and perception. The utility regarding the latter is found in sports psychology when athletes underperform based on previous proven ability, and things like mantras and relaxation techniques may be helpful in training those aspects. But by and large for most cases for most of us, I think "It's the training, stupid!"

    ReplyDelete
  7. Within training groups, i see individuals of similar fitness who are willing to push themselves to different levels. Some push and push when the suffering starts and others simply slow down. I think a persons mental strength/personality decides how far a persons central governor can be delayed. Some people simply cannot handle extreme sensations of the mind and body that hard training produces. No pain, no gain, it's about how hard you're willing to go.

    ReplyDelete
  8. My problem with Waterlogged is that it doesn't pass the straight faced test. There is a Recommended Daily Allowance of salt. That means you need a certain amount every day. Why? Because your body passes it out through sweat, etc.

    So it is therefore only logical that if you are exercising and sweating much more and for longer periods of time, you will need more and more salt to retain the desired balance.

    There are numerous scientific studies that show that a common cause of muscle cramps is lack of salt (you can Google it, U of Oklahoma did one a few years ago). There are numerous anecdotes (way too many to name) of athletes who had cramping problems that were eased by ingestion of salt. Noakes says its probably some placebo effect. Really? What a terribly pathetic answer - all he'd have to do is go to an ultramarathon and hand out fake salt tablets at the aid station tables and watch what happens. His explanation is elementarily simple to prove or disprove, so why hasn't he?

    He makes some very good points, but the basic premise makes absolutely no sense.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Quote from Noakes' book, p118:

      "Not a single published scientific paper shows that blood electrolyte concentrations, including the sodium concentration, are abnormal at the time subjects develop exercise associated muscle cramps (EAMC)."

      I have not reviewed all of the dozens of papers that Noakes references on this subject in Waterlogged, but I trust that he is giving an objective review of the data available. Perhaps there is a sodium-related effect that is not currently understood or is undiscovered, but it seems clear, based on data available to date, that low blood sodium is not correlated with EAMC.

      Delete
  9. Aside from all the written opinions (like mine) and "studies", lots of personal experience tells me that sodium supplements work for me. When it's hotter, I cramp more and salt helps. When it's cooler, I can get away with none. In 100s where it's pretty warm in the day and damn cold at night (e.g. Bear 100) I start getting twinges of cramps around 11am and have to take varying amounts of sodium (with increasing portions of water to match) to keep the body free to move. As it gets cooler, like 6pm, the salt intake tails off and I can go for the rest of the race without any sodium (and typically very little water). The last 4 hours of San Diego I took in zero sodium and about 10 oz water. Of course, I was moving very slowly in fairly cold conditions. I guess my point is that based on the fact that I need varying amounts of sodium to match the conditions and effort level I feel it's more than just a placebo effect (my cramps don't go away by looking at salt) and has a direct effect on my muscles' ability to work correctly.

    Joe Uhan guinea pigged himself at WS100 this year trying to follow Noakes' recommendation and ended up cramping… until he finally took in supplemental sodium, which alleviated the cramping. Here's part 2 of his article. http://www.irunfar.com/2012/08/waterlogged-part-ii-trials-questions-and-suggestions-regarding-hydration-and-ultramarathons.html

    Personally, I don't give a crap what others write or do; I know from mistakes and experience it works for me. It's like debating running form.

    As for a central governor, look at folks who think a 10 mile run is impossible and then look at someone like Marshall Ulrich and his run across the US. Perception and physical/mental conditioning (and natural ability potential).

    ReplyDelete
  10. Paul: I agree with what you're saying there, but when I hear only talk about "pain" (only) is when I feel like it's an oversimplification. Part of training is getting familiar with pain, but a very large part of it is /avoidance/ of pain by the body becoming more efficient at movement, metabolism and clearing waste products, etc. And part of that pain/discomfort in longer races are important biological signals (e.g. dehydration and low blood sugar) that are better addressed by satisfying those needs than by pushing through it. People can indeed push through pain to make incremental gains, but by and large performance improvement follows well-known long, sweeping curves based on training. People win races that feel better and hurt less than other ones that they ran more slowly.
    2 more observations: 1. Nobody trains by /racing/ every single workout as hard as possible 2. We could easily test the "pain threshold" hypothesis and see to what degree it correlates with results.

    To my knowledge, it hasn't been done. But I think people read Noakes theory as "pain" and not so much "experience" management, which I think is closer to what he's shown. The CG 'evidence' I've seen is that people can go faster/farther than they thought when they're racing against very slightly faster "rabbit," or when they're artificially told they're going slower so they pick up the pace. Still, the improvements are an increment on their capability. To me, that (only) suggests that adding cues of competition aids in reaching maximum potential -- a very old Darwinian observation more than anything!

    My opinion, though!

    ReplyDelete
  11. In my experience, people of exceptional ability tend to underestimate that ability in their appraisals, and attribute a disproportionate amount of success to "desire" or other personality traits. I see it again and again in all walks of life. The same thing occurs with income levels and life situations (so-and-so is just not trying hard enough).

    No doubt the ability to tough it out is required for competitive success, but as Mike said its effect is relative to your baseline capabilities.

    That said, I'll be the first to admit I don't care to endure much pain. heh

    ReplyDelete
  12. drunken philosophizin' ...going off of what mtnrunner2 said:

    a) is the desire for suffering a key trait in successful running? and in that case, is a masochistic runner who loves to hurt truly pushing themselves to a threshold of pain way higher than the rest of us?

    b) or are we all suffering equally? is the new 5k runner who comes across the line looking like death hurting just as badly as the elite ultrarunner who comes across the line and collapses?

    eat salt or don't. i don't see a lot of people dying of salt intake or salt deficit...so, do what tastes right, i say.


    ReplyDelete
  13. There is a lot of good stuff here. The interview with Noakes was good. One thing that I think (if I remember right) that is discussed is the difference between cause versus relief of symptoms. I believe the theory is that salt deficit will not cause a cramp but can relieve the symptoms. Not quite sure on the mechanism here, but the classic experiment is to give a cramping subject something like pickle juice which alleviates the cramp faster than the sodium is absorbed. So some sort of neuromuscular thing goes on that eliminates the cramp. Basically it means that ingesting salt will relieve a cramp but will not necessarily prevent its occurrence. Kind of confusing to me (should have got my PhD in physiology...) and I'm not going to even pretend I know what is going on here.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Damn...I wish I trained hard enough to warrant salt. One day I will again. I think I'll hire Paul, above, to coach me! :)

    Glad you're feeling better.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Great back and forth in here all. Thanks for the comments.

    I have to sort of grin at the salt paradox. Apparently if you taste it, it stops cramping. But really, there is no need to take it. Unless you want to stop cramping. uhhh ...

    I do think that cramping is typically caused by bringing your muscles/facia to a place where they are not accustomed. When I deal with cramps on Pikes, I am pretty sure that has little to do with a lack of salt (or a lack of tasting salt I guess) and more about the fact that I have not adequately trained to be used to 7800 feet of climbing over 13 miles at those paces.

    But if sipping pickle juice helps, even if it has no biological-physiological merit other than serving as some sort of not understood placebo - why would I fight that?

    ReplyDelete
  16. Noakes statement is that the body has sufficient stores of NaCl so as not to be "catastrophically low" from endurance exercise, suggested from blood sodium level measurements. Still, there are many possibilities on the salt thing. In the last couple of years (only), we've just learned the structure of the salt taste receptor in the tongue; we've learned about other taste (e.g.) sweet receptors *all over the body*; and we know that activating various receptors in different parts of the body can induce hormonal changes (e.g. sweet->insulin).

    Lost among Noakes strong statements is the fact that not knowing how something works is different than being certain of what's going on.
    If cramping is the body's protective mechanism, there may be sufficient salt in the bloodstream, but maybe not somewhere locally...the muscle itself? the neurons? Are all ions and water optimally available in fatigued muscles and nerves? (Since /very low/ concentrations are needed, I doubt that they are insufficient...but I don't know that we've studied it. Blood is studied the most, but considering it's importance to all tissue, I wouldn't be surprised if blood sodium levels were preferentially preserved by the body (to the detriment of skeletal muscle).
    And: are the studies which measure serum sodium levels *after* the activity and cramp sufficent? (IMHO, no).

    So it's not surprising that the body tastes salt and changes state in the body by the anticipation of using it And it is more quickly absorbed orally so it makes sense that any effects would happen most quickly that way (vs. taking a pill absorbed in the gut). Maybe it "needs" the salt in way we don't understand. Maybe we actually 'need' another electrolyte like potassium, and evolutionarily we ate those salts together (just hypothesizing).

    In any case, the "paradox" so far is only "we don't understand how it works yet." Lots of cool stuff to learn still: remember to volunteer for studies and to fund science research! =)

    ReplyDelete