This is fun:
Casey N is awesome.
Joe Grant has a great interview with Pablo V. I remember a lot times running 20-23 miles without drinking anything at all because that was kinda like for wimps, which is stupid, I mean bizarre, but that’s the way it was. That was the mentality back then.
Although that might be trumped by: If you’re scared shitless, try not to show it.
=======
Recently one of our kids got a letter to be tested for the Talented and Gifted program at his school. We received a similar letter for our other child a few years back. I have a mix of feelings on these programs. Of course, the initial reaction is one of a bit of pride: Hey! My kid is gifted!
But that is offset with other concerns.
My “think-about-it-too-much” head gets concerned about this TAG program thing on two fronts. First, the titling of what is gifted. Just because you read a bit more than the average kid, or do well with math at the curriculum level does not mean you are gifted. In fact, even if you are the school valedictorian, I would say you are probably not gifted. Few are truly gifted. In running circles, Matt Carpenter, KJ are gifted … they have V02max values that are over 90. That is a gift. Examples outside of running: Mozart was gifted. Newton was gifted. Picasso was gifted.
I have concern when we make everything a talent, everything world class, everything best practice. It ties to the “everyone is a winner” mentality that we seem to be grappling with as a society. When we use words like “talented and gifted” for a sixth grader who does well at math and reads a lot, I think it waters down the meaning of that word.
But more importantly (and second to the above) the term gifted carries a sense of entitlement to me. You can ride on the coat tails of talent if not careful, rather than work hard. I cringe when some categorizes me as talented when discussing my running. It seems to overlook an important component: hard work. Okay, sure, I have some modicum of talent, but I would not call me talented on a grander stage. And to that end, I like to think that my work has taken that talent fairly far.
I think telling a kid they are gifted has a potential risk: you are gifted, you are smart, wow – look how great you are. This could possibly leave the kid thinking that all things should come easy to them. What happens when they fail? Are they no longer gifted? Will they get up, brush themselves off and work hard to overcome? Rather than tell a kid how great they are, tell them how great they are because of the work they have put in – not because of easy talents.
A gift is nothing without work.
=========
Evening – 10.6 miles. Felt cruddy. Easy.
Tell me about that Grandpa Carolla.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TR-QA6xvBtg
Haha. Figured you'd be able to relate!
DeleteSeems to me like 'gifted' has taken on the meaning a bit above average. It no longer has the meaning truly exceptional natural talent. I think gifted programs are a bit problematic in that they imply good students succeed due to natural talent rather than hard work. I good listen/read discusses this vs. other cultures: http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2012/11/12/164793058/struggle-for-smarts-how-eastern-and-western-cultures-tackle-learning
ReplyDeleteIn the end, talent + hard work appears to be the recipe for success. All of the examples you point out illustrate that point. They are people who were extremely talented and worked a lot to be the best.
Thanks for that read - I will dig into that.
DeleteNow that I've begun to help with coaching young athletes, I've seen the "gift" wasted and I've seen the "ungifted" exploited!
ReplyDeleteNick's right about the hard work.
Isn't it maddening to see a gift wasted?
Deleteas a kid (6-9th grade) i was in "gifted" classes. I can tell by being around the other kids they did seem a bit entitled. My parents gave me the choice to go into the "gifted" program and I jumped in... which I believe was because in 6th grade there were a couple girls i thought were cute...
ReplyDeleteby 9th grade i was over it. i working harder to get a B- and doing more homework than my friends getting A's in "non-gifted" classes. I was smart enough to figure that one out and I told my parents i was dropping out of the gifted classes mid 9th grade... it gave me time to focus on baseball and girls... and get straight A's!
not really adding much to the conversation... just my story of the gifted program. I don't see the point if you already have a "smart" kid. Now classes where you make actually get college credit may be worth while.
That college credit thing is another post I am drumming up. The freshman kid has a slew of AP or advanced classes on the slate for next year. That is great but I hope her head does not pop.
DeleteI am grinning at your gift to beat the gifted system, play ball and chase the ladies.
Exactly what I did! My sophomore year of HS was a waste academically in AP/Honors Chem etc. Dropped that shit, got good grades, and played a hell of a lot better on the field the rest of the way... The combo academic/athletic scholarships were the reason I had very little (and now eliminated) school debt.
DeleteMore to come on this on an upcoming post but we just did parent teacher conferences. Every teacher wants her to do some advanced class, some AP class. She is a highly motivated kid, so she is thinking about that ... but it is a huge load (in my mind). It also seems that none of the teachers are looking at the big picture of her full load (which is somewhat expected).
DeleteI've taught high school geology and earth science on and off for decades - the gifted subject is yet another novel I could write about :); I promise you I share your sentiments exactly. Do you know how many parents I have dealt with whose "gifted" child I have failed? Just because they were told in 5th grade they were gifted does not warrant them a diploma if they don't do anything with their so-called gift. The 'no child left behind' is a crock of sh!t and schools push these advanced programs on kids that truly do not belong there to boost up their rankings. It's why I don't teach full-time anymore! I believe in my heart each and every one of us has a special talent...whether it's running or the ability to be a compassionate individual or able to speed read - whatever 'it' is, it's something we've searched our souls and hearts to find and worked hard enough to earn it.
ReplyDeleteAs for running, per se, I don't think you have to be 'fast' to be a gifted runner....the gift to run comes from inside you; it is not a value placed by a finish line time. If you train hard and finish last in a race, you still have a gift (IMO :)).
Thanks for the comment Jill. I struggle however with the "we all have a special talent" comment. That is not to say there is not potential value all of us.
DeleteGifts in running can come in a variety of ways - durability, endurance, climbing gear, etc. But to your point - running itself is a gift. Recent posts by Geoff Roes further illustrates that point.
Great insight, GZ. 100% agree. A gift only translates to success with hard work and a commitment to put it to good and productive use.
ReplyDeleteThanks Lisa!
DeleteInteresting - this showed up in my email from Seth Godin today regarding gifts. Thought you'd enjoy it.
ReplyDelete***
TITLE: Actually, it goes the other way
Wouldn't it be great to be gifted? In fact...
It turns out that choices lead to habits.
Habits become talents.
Talents are labeled gifts.
You're not born this way, you get this way.
***
This message is subtle, but pretty profound, and right in line with your thoughts.
Lis
Lisa - I saw that this AM as well (I am subscribed to the Godin feed also). I was going to post it up today.
DeleteIn my 20s I used to deny the concept of talent, and was more of the mindset of Gladwell's 10000 hours. There was no talent, only hard work. I still think that is a better mindset to have, but I recognize that there are those that are gifted.
I think for myself it is better to think I have no great gifts other than the people in my life. And that my choices (ala Godin) are determinants as to what I get out of the small tidings I have. If I think I am gifted, then I think I have expectation. Expectation leads to suffering, refer to Siddhartha I guess.