Tuesday, October 21, 2008

Torching overtraining

Mileage has been a bit lower than I have wanted.  I could easily get over this - if I got my butt out of bed in the morning and got some miles in before going to work.  But honestly, I enjoy that morning sleep and that slow wake up.  I can make the morning pre-sun run work once or twice a week, but I don't seem to have the will to deal with it everyday.

And that thought leads me to today's useless thought:  over training. 

I am pretty sure I have NEVER over trained.  I am very sure I have not trained as effectively or efficiently as I could have, but I am pretty confident that I have not over trained.  I guess you could argue that whenever I got injured, I did over train ... yeah, there could be some truth in that ... but that aside:  I have not put together enough miles, intense sessions, big weeks, etc where I drove myself into this pit of despair, doom, fatigue and diminishing results.

So this is where the post gets me into trouble ... I am sure this does occur for some people.  I have met the personalities that can effectively train themselves into absolute oblivion.  They are rare. 

It is like the Marine I saw at a club while I was in the Air Force.  All night the guy would have this bet for pitchers of beer.  The bet was he would put his forearm up to your opposing forearm.  A lit cigarette was dropped between the two limbs.  Whoever pulled their arm away first had to buy the next pitcher.  When the challenge came to me, I decided just to spare my arm and buy the brew to keep everyone the happier.  This guy was rare because not only was he up for the competition, he revealed in it to the point of self destruction.  He closed the night by putting the cigarette out with his mouth. 

Okay, that tangent aside ... I think it is rare for a people to be able to train themselves into total crash.  I hear a lot of folks talking about, well - I need to back off so I don't get over trained.  There is some logic to what they are saying but I don't think it is being over trained.  I think they are really saying they need to back off so their body can recover from their last training session and absorb what training they have done.   This might be a slight degree of difference from over training I guess, but I see it as different. 

I don't know ... I have a tough time buying into the "over training" statement when the mileage is at 50 miles a week.  I think the key here is not over training but "effective and appropriate training."  Certainly someone who is running 20 miles a week is risking injury if they suddenly ramp to 80.  Coaching (either via self or via someone else) would provide insight into what would be an appropriate ramp up.  My point is it is rare for me to actually see the person who is wringing the most out of their training time, managing their load effectively AND training themselves to the point of diminishing returns.   

Flame away.

7 comments:

  1. I think over-training is either
    A) bullshit or B) related to some sort of mental disorder ala your Army friend or someone trying to prove something to him/her self. Because no one else gives shit.

    In other words, I agree with you, GZ.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This, as usual, agrees with and contradicts what other people say. How's that for a worthless, useless introductory comment?

    Anyways, on Tim's Blob Blobby Blob (see comment down below at October 20, 2008 2:15 PM) he says all these things are good, but specificity matters.

    Specifically, he is saying that rather than do 120 miles a week, he would be better to do whatever mileage is required to provide more realistic race preperation during his workouts than what he's been doing.

    I think this goes back to the RCQ^2 post too.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yeah - I saw that. I think there is a time and place for high mileage training with no concern for speed but ... ultimately you are best equipped to do as much mileage as to can without compromising speed work and vice versa. Or do as much quantity as to you can without compromising quantity and do as much quality as you can without compromising quantity.

    Sure, maybe I can do a workout or two with someone who is better than me. But will I be able to keep up with the mileage? And maybe I can run a 120 mile week ... but if it is all at 15 min miles what good is that if I am trying to train for a fast 5k?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Overtraining == Underrecovering

    Do note that there are other factors that impact recovery other than merely the stresses of training. Work, family, and social "demands;" nutrition; hydration; muscle therapy (stretching, massage, etc.); as well as rest. Also note that any and all systems (c-v, m-s, energy, etc.) have their own recovery requirements.

    ReplyDelete
  5. 給飛行
    (I think I said that right) .... (who the heck are you anyway?)

    Totally agree.

    GZ

    ReplyDelete
  6. Merely a well-meaning friend of yore. See you at Mags on Sunday?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Unfortunately no ... I will be hanging out with Ariel the Mermaid in Florida. And Snow White. And Sleeping Beauty. And Belle.

    ReplyDelete