Thursday, October 3, 2013

VO2 max math to not be math

A few folks have commented that the math referred to in my posts over the last couple of days has been a bit much.  My response is that it is pretty easy.  V02 max is a measured value of how much oxygen your body can take up in a period of time.  There is a part of this measure that is related to your body weight as well.  So To determine V02 max, you typically go to a lap, get on a treadmill, get a mask on you that tracks your intake and expired gases and run increasingly harder to failure.  The value is calculated from that.  The value is typically expressed as milliliters of 02 per min per kilogram.  So in other words how many milliliters of 02 can you process in a minute per your weight in kilograms.  (side note, as the kilograms are a denominator in the equation, as you drop weight, your V02 will rise … to some degree … obviously there is a point of diminishing returns and danger there).

There are super high values for some athletes, like 90 or higher.  You will hear these sort of values for guys like Carpenter (90.2) or Kilian (92).  A sedentary person may have a value half that or even lower.  The rest of us recreational hobby athletes fall somewhere in the middle. VO2 max is not an absolute predictor of endurance success but it is a fair one.  I met a guy that have claimed to have had VO2 max in excess of 80.  It was sort of hard to believe because he often finished behind me in races and mine was lower.  But his form, or what is referred often as economy was horrible.  He may have been taking up all that wonderful oxygen much better than everyone in a race field, but he was using it to send his energy in every direction except forward while running.  In other words, a V02 max that is high is a very nice number to have (and partially genetically determined), it is not a guarantee of success or doom in running.

Okay - so VO2 values are not something that are absolutely obtained unless you go to the lab – AND those values might not mean much anyway.  In other words, like HR or pace or any other value it is a number to potentially consider in the definition of a training program. 

This site lists some folks and their V02s … As much as you might find it interesting that Carpenter was up there, and that guys like Pre and Lance had values of 84, I find it as interesting that Jim Ryun and Steve Scott who were record holders in the mile had lower values then the aforementioned VO2 kings. 

Jack Daniels, realizing that most people don’t have access to a V02 lab test put together a set of tables called VDOT tables.  These tables project what average performances would be for a corresponding V02 max.  So it is a construct that he put together.  But again, it is not absolute.  Across large populations, we’d probably see a bulk of the people fall into his predicted time sets for a particular V02 but there would obviously and clearly be exceptions.   Daniels then took these predicted race times and projected appropriate training paces for different distances. 

The VDOT tables are a model.  A popular saying in my work the George Box quote:  “All models are wrong but some are useful.”  Consider this when you calculate anything in your training program – including MAF HR.  In other words, you are a case study of one so you are unique.  But you are probably not as unique as you would to think you are.  The VDOT tables are fun for me.  I can take my personal data, see where it sits in the table and then begin to muse how I can move it around.  That is about it with the math.

I also got the comment that my approach here seems a bit more focused than what I was doing with Pikes.  I don’t think that is completely true.  I would say preparing for a flat 8k on a 2k grass loop course at 5400 feet is a much easier problem to approach for me than a marathon that goes up and down at an average of 11.5% grade from 6800 to 14100 feet.  There are just less variables to consider in the former.  If that comes across as better focus, I guess that is true, but it is simply because there are less balls to juggle in that riddle. 

22 comments:

  1. Not so much math as much as established ex phys, and I like what you've been posting, and agree with your assessments. One little (actually, big) underappreciated (and understudied) bit is the fact that you've reached/crushed some of those numbers before -- that's different than someone trying to bust through a plateau he's never reached before, of course with an age and mileage-dependency as well. Curious to see how it goes with you, I love the approach and the aggressive but reachable goal.
    What bores the hell out of me is when people ask the same questions, overandoverandover, on certain podcasts, looking for very specific (free) advice on what effort they should train at, but being inflexible and perhaps counterproductive about the workouts and races they decided to do.

    I love predictor workouts. You said it well with the fact that it's population-based, not necessarily individual, but most people will be near that average, and with experience or the help of a coach will figure out in which direction (e.g. if they lean toward endurance or speed).

    It does not surprise me or others that endurance athletes have higher VO2 maxes than milers; here's an interesting (old) chart.
    A miler that worked toward the same aerobic efficiency of a longer distance runner would be wasting their time training sub-optimally (and wouldn't be known as a miler)!
    But clearly there are interesting exceptions of individual athletes that have different tradeoffs of aerobic efficiency vs. running economy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Mike!

      I have clearly heard Friel saying that the guy who is coming off the couch, or rather been the inconsistent trainer is more likely to see significant performance gains over the guy who has been a regular trainer.

      I suspect that I am the regular trainer, but hope that my shift in focus helps me out. I also hope that a shift in the dietary regime (note shift, not 180 change) helps. And I am hopeful that some weight training - a place that I am coming from where I have not been a consistent trainer - provides me a leg up.

      If not, it is worth trying!

      I am in agreement with you on the podcasts. A new game I have started to play with the Lucho/Tawnee ATX casts is to guess the answer before they say it. I am usually right on the mark. That is not a sign of my great knowledge on these things as much as it is I have heard nearly all the questions before. I fail miserably on any technical bike questions though.

      Too bad I have a face made for the big screen and not for podcasting I guess.

      Your note on the milers / longer distance guys is interesting to me because there are so many conversations going on now about how mile speed is the predictor for marathon success (consider Farrah for example).

      I love the predictor stuff. I used to love how I could be told I was in 2:24 marathon shape based off a 4:13 1500. And I used to love how that was completely untrue!

      Delete
    2. re: mile vs. marathon prediction
      "Necessary, but not sufficient" -- if certain benchmarks at shorter distances are not achieved, than correlated ones at longer distances usually are even harder to achieve. But achieving the success at shorter distances only suggests rather than guarantees the potential for the longer ones.

      A *world-class* miler that did focused marathon-specific training would no longer be in mile-PR shape, right? But correspondingly, VO2max would increase as aerobic efficiency was trained. On the flipside, the mile might even be more than 10% ATP-fueled; mostly anaerobic glycolysis for the rest; and very little (in comparison) need to be efficient in using oxygen to oxidize fats.

      Delete
    3. Yup. If there is anything controversial in what you said it is that V02 would increase ... there seems to be a general belief that V02 is a number that you are fixed with and can't train up. I don't quite buy that. I think there is a genetic limit of course, but if you can train it down, you can certainly train it up.

      I'd have to stew on your mile break up. I think it is still something like 95% aerobic. But fuel consumption is clearly going to be glycogen.

      Delete
  2. To be clear, I was talking about a 3:45 miler, and using a rule-of-thumb of up to ~2 minutes of glycolysis-fueled running, but that might be generous. I'm seeing some disparities at a quick glance (some sources saying a hard mile is predominantly anaerobic; other sources saying differently), but the larger point was that the mile is at least 20-30% or more anaerobic, with a marathon being almost purely aerobic.

    As for VO2max, it's most definitely trainable, in both directions, as you mentioned, with a trainable range that is limited genetically, so I'm talking about it fluctuating by more like 10% or so, and the fact that running economy is also important. We might imagine a XC skier or cyclist switching disciplines and seeing a dip in VO2max but improvement in running speed, yet still being well within the 80s. Let's see if we can find an example of an elite moving up in distance and having VO2max recorded when trained optimally for different distances...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Perhaps the cross skiing example is a good one to look at since most of the elite and Olympic athletes in this sport participate in all events from 'sprints' (about 1.5-3 km for the men (events last from 3 minutes to about 9 minutes, depending on the course)) to the 'marathon' (50 km, which lasts from about 2hrs to about 2:30). Although sprint specialists have emerged (Norway in particular has fielded sprint competitors that look more like linebackers than cross country skiers) the most successful distance (30-50 km) athletes can dominate the sprints (and all other distances) as well, Petter Northug (Norway) being the most current example. Northug's VO2 max is reported to be 90+. This argues that, at least in cross country skiing, an athlete can be in 'mile PR' shape and 'marathon PR' shape at the same time (in World Cups, World Championships, and at the Olympics all of the events occur well within a two week period). Also, for Northug (and others like him in the past) the 'sprint PR' and 'mararthon PR' can also be 'worlds best' at the time. The translation of this to running is perhaps not direct as there appear to be no examples of such dominance across the distances. However, this does indicate that 'mile PR' is a first order predictor of speed at longer distances, perhaps with enough uncertainty that it lacks much utility.

      I still find Crowthers ruminations on the subject of 'training the big 3' to be valid although now dated:

      http://faculty.washington.edu/crowther/Misc/RBC/model2.shtml

      Too bad he stopped keeping comprehensive tabs on the literature and writing about it.

      Delete
    2. Great stuff, Robert, thanks! I wonder if the longer sprints are getting closer to middle distance, but I think the success of the short, ~3-min sprints is an interesting comparison to milers. Historically, did everyone do all the distances -- was there enough prestige/incentive to specialize?

      GZ, despite amateurs being more likely to see VO2max increase with endurance training, I totally need to back off that for elite athletes without further data. I haven't found anything comprehensive regarding specific athletes over time, but some discussion of Paula R. being consistent in the 70s even as she moved up in distance (from a teenager), and even Lance's was measured high in his teen years.
      It's possible, instead, that good, young runners with high VO2maxes show more potential to succeed at longer distances w/ increased training, and are likely to "discover" that through success. I'm not as surprised that top milers may have slightly lower VO2maxes than top long-distance runners because of the percentage of aerobic contribution, which is why the sprint/middle/long-distance groupings generally make sense. It is also interesting to note that various VO2 max testing protocols take ~8-12 minutes.

      Delete
    3. Robert - thanks for that reference. It is a solid post (and not that long once you cull out all the references ... imagine that, someone who actually references their work!). I am looking forward to reading more of his posts.

      "...workouts at race pace are almost always a good idea regardless of what that pace happens to be ..."

      The XC skiing consideration is interesting. I wonder what makes running more unique is the impact situation. The test there would be the V02 max values I guess for other impact endurance sports (biking and swimming come to mind). Perhaps the specialization (like the lineback sprinters you mention) has already been played out there. So similar to Mike's question, I wonder how much the history of specialization plays out in skiing.

      In any case, you start playing with a genetic limit (gift) of a 80 plus VO2 max, well ... that is a very nice number to have in endurance sports (there of course have to be a lot of other numbers to consider ... but it is a good lottery number!)

      Delete
    4. Mike ... 8-12 minutes? It took me twice as long to get all that stuff hooked up!

      Good points. Raises the question for me (ala the Sports Gene versus 10000 Hours) has there been a runner who started with a V02 max that was low (say 60) and then cranked that to success (arbitrary but let's say a Oly medal) ... or did all of them start with high maxes anyway?

      Delete
    5. Mike and GZ- It is sort of interesting as the 'sprint' event in cross country skiing is recent. It was added at the World Cup level in the past decade to spur spectator interest. I suspect that we are just beginning to see the specialization and that, in time, the cross country skiing sprints will be dominated by certain body-types most suited to that distance. However, the wild card is that cross country skiing is essentially a core strength-dominated sport that recruits nearly all the major muscle groups in a primary way.These muscle groups cannot be efficiently utilized for power or endurance without a substantive core strength. If you look at some of the core workouts that cross country skiers do you will understand how important the core is. These workouts are brutal. In the end, this may result in a similar optimal body structure/muscle mass for both short and long distances. Just a thought...

      GZ- btw, I totally agree with the quote you picked out.

      Concerning VO2 max, I think you may find the odd true elite athlete in endurance sport with a 'low' VO2 max (low being 65 or so), but it is rare in my experience. The opposite is not uncommon and reinforces the additive/multiplicative effect of the mental side on success.

      Also if you have been VO2 max tested on equipment like what is used at places like the OTCs, you will know that the variation in results is relatively large and dependent on the vagaries of your 'feel' on test day. Looking at a set of VO2 max (and other) tests over a couple years is a much more accurate way to evaluate but many athletes never have access to such data since it is expensive and not readily available. I have seen an athlete tested for VO2 max at 68 on one occasion and then 82 on another not long thereafter- turns out this athlete is actually, after numerous tests over a reasonable period (a couple of years), a consistent high 70's. One should put such variation into the thought process on VO2 max data.

      Delete
    6. Good points on the equipment ... which actually probably lends one back to the more general VDOT tables anyway. I mean, what good is the number unless you know what to do with it.

      My test had me in the mid sixties about a decade ago. Over at CU ... maybe it was right, maybe not. I recall having a mixed reaction. I mean I would have been really stoked if it came back as 90, but then I would have been a bit pissed that my performances had not lined up with that.

      Virgin seems to be the lowest I see as a guy having elite success and he is still an 81. I have yet to come across a 70 something elite distance runner.

      Delete
    7. GZ- the VDOT tables work for me, even as I age. Age should put some sort of non-linearity into the predictions but I have not seen that yet.

      As an athlete, having straddled the period between no VO2 max testing/HR monitoring (the 60's and 70's) and when it first started being used (late 70's early 80's), I can say that the coaches seemed to have the expected VO2 max values pretty well categorically predicted once they became calibrated. In other words they knew from various on-the-ground performances about where, on the VO2 max scale, the athletes were going to test. I know that this ability to predict lasted well into the 1990's when my interaction at the elite level came to an end. I should think that, for recreational athletes, the ground-tests are more than sufficient to calibrate ultimate potential performances. Most areas have either published or word-of-mouth records for various loops, sections, or hills and these serve as a means for calibration and progress against some 'elite' athletes- if these 'elites' have published their times. One can also use race courses and associated splits, as you know (i.e. Pikes). The town I live in has a 3 km Vertical K race every year that has had and continues to have many endurance Olympian competitors. All of the endurance Olympians, in their respective primes, have finished within about 2-3% of the record time (about 36 minutes), although a non-Olympian has the record (a local who focuses on this event and who is/has been 'on the bubble' w/r/t making an Olympic Team). Such events (or just doing a TT on the course) are a good source for prediction of one's own expected ultimate abilities and progress with training.

      Agreed on the 'true' elites having 80+ VO2 max, where 'true' is world championship and/or Olympic level. This gets fuzzy in less competitive/embryonic endurance sports where the fields may not be very deep.

      Delete
    8. More good stuff, guys, thanks!
      In a cursory look, I'm also seeing quite a bit of noise in measured VO2max for the same athlete, as both of you alluded to. Ideally, I wanted to see what happened to a successful shorter middle-distance runner moving up in distance, vs. those that didn't, and if VO2max was already differentiated and predictive, or changed as the athlete trained more for endurance, and presumably Type II muscle fiber type ratios changed.
      Since some of the athletes were already measuring high in their teens, what we really need is twin studies!

      Delete
    9. I got distracted at looking at VO2 stuff and tried to figure out who Robert was based on the info in his comment.

      I am also curious as to what the V02 max values would be for elite ultra marathoners. As far as I know we only have numbers for Carpenter and Kilian. I imagine that Sage is up there as a 2:16 marathoner, as is Max (2:14, 8:20 steeple), but I am curious if the "80 rule" is applicable for guys like Clark, Tony, Hal, etc

      Delete
    10. http://www.trainingbible.com/joesblog/2009/11/vo2max-and-race-performance.html
      Frank Shorter was ~72
      Bill Rodgers was ~78

      Delete
    11. Well there you go. 72! I think he picked that just because that is the year he won the marathon.

      His economy was ridiculous. I ran with the guy about 15 years ago when he showed up at the BRR and he was like a feather floating over the road. I saw Rogers and it was the same. It was like his feet never hit the ground.

      Delete
  3. Good stuff Geo. With winter coming, this is the kind of thing I start to think about again. Thanks for stirring the pot.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Now you have more time to coach! ;)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, but I need to progress my technique as a coach to be more than "go out hard, then pick it up and finish strong."

      Delete
    2. That's as good as any coach I've ever had ;).
      You have a heart - that's I think worth more than any "plan".
      One day I'll convince you :).

      Thanks for the uroy nod - haha.

      Delete
  5. The VO2 max list is interesting. That kid who's first on the list...he has a future in cycling if he applies himself! Right now there's a guy sitting on his sofa who weighs 300 pounds and is eating chips and Ho-Ho's--completely unaware that he has a 95 VO2 max. There's lost potential everywhere. The people on that list are just those who found out about their potential and worked hard toward it.

    Wyatt

    ReplyDelete