Tuesday, January 27, 2009

Wednesday 012709 10 miles Get Nutty on the Mill

So I saw Justin's post on the mill and we started an off line conversation.  The mills at my office go up to 14 mph.  That is a 4:16 mile pace for those of you converting at home.  Or pretty damn fast.  My mill at home goes to 12mph or a five minute mile.  In any case, all these mills have way more than I can handle because they can all crank up to an incline of 15% or some 700 plus feet of gain in a mile.

Anyway, Justin clued me in that this runner we know had done 14mph on the mill for 3 minutes but then had to quit because it felt like he was going to be thrown off.  It suddenly dawned me that I had never even tried the mill at this speed, and I was wondering "why the hell not?"  I had no aspirations or false belief that I could hold a near three quarter mile of a run at that pace but I was going to see what the speed felt like for a half minute or so.

So - this whole run was about strides, and essentially goofing on on the treadmill.  Let's get that out there first.

Did a mile warm up and then a few strides for a minute or so at slower speeds (10mph, 11 mph, 12mph) and then began to get to business.  I did one at 13mph (4:36 mile) and that did not feel too bad.  It was taking about 10 seconds for the mill to ramp up from the 7:30's I was doing to the 12, 13 (I was starting the ramp up at 10 seconds before the count of 30).  I then upped the next one to 13.5 (4:26), but about 5 seconds in I said "screw this" and cranked it to 14.

At 14mph, a mill is pretty loud.  I had gone in this office gym of people from jogging to freaking sprinting and it was getting noticed.  The first 20 seconds were fine (after the ramp up - which was now taking closer to 15 seconds so I had to wait for that), but then I could feel that I was beginning to need to focus towards the end.  I did three more of these after plenty of rest (like 2 minutes each at 8:30 pace) and then did one more at 13.5.

All this brought me to about five miles in 33 minutes.  To switch it up, I cranked up the incline and decided I do a half dozen strides of 30 seconds at 15% grade.  I started with 10mph (6.0 min /mile).  MUCH HARDER.  I mean way way way harder.  I realize that might be a bit that I was gassed a touch from the prior strides but even so - these were harder.  I back the pace off on the subsequent ones to a much more manageable 8.x mph.  I kept the recoveries at 15% but at a really slow recovery pace of like 4 mph.  So - the next 1.5 miles were covered over 17 min (6.5 over 50+!).  I did six of these strides, brought the mill back to my typical .5 percent and finished the run out with a few strides in the 10-11 mph range.  Total run - 10 miles, 75 minutes. 

But fun.

17 comments:

  1. DUDE! Fun on the rat wheel!!! Great post. Some of your "speed sessions" have inspired me lately and I actually did a GZ version today, but come on man!

    ReplyDelete
  2. JP - I just read your post and will also comment there.

    I do see the treadmill almost as a game of sorts. That is fine, but it can be dangerous I think - because it is a game! I think it can force a driving of running hard a lot if one "just plays the game."

    I also was thinking about some of these paces today and what they mean. 4:16 is really only a 32s 200m ... not really that fast (but pretty fast when added up over 8 of them in a row ... as Lydiard said ... it is not about speed, it is about enduring speed!)

    So ... what does that mean? Well, for me ... it probably means that I need to be less impressed that I was running at 14mph, and realize this is probably what I ought to be doing my strides at anyway! When I was running low 16s for 5k, my 200 strides were often low 30s, 31. Doing strides at 5 min pace ain't bad, it is just my experience has been that my strides need to build to be faster than that!

    I am thinking of playing some more games ... like if I can do a 2:08 half mile on the mill. Got to have some fun while on it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. GZ, i need to read more Noakes, but give me some feedback: the time I took off from say late Nov (when I kinda got that cold that's hung around for a loooong time) until say two weeks ago feels like it's really put me back - I feel pretty out of shape based on my running recently. I'm not wearing a HRM, just running and going pretty "Steady" but it's making me pretty "out of breath." I'm probably out of my zone, but feel great afterwards. What do you think? Am I skipping my base by doing these kinds of workouts now? My base was so long and exaggerated last year. Now I'm sorta or pretty uncomfortable on some runs. Part of me thinks I'll just get more comfortable. Obviously I'll have easier runs, but I'm being assigned "steady" runs. A big part of me feels like I have to run this way to get faster. I built a nice base last year but don't feel like I got very fast. What do you think, my friend?

    ReplyDelete
  4. It clicked for me a bit today on the potential of the rat wheel. I did my workout at lunch today before I'd read your "full-tilt" speed workout this afternoon. I think my biggest problem is relating speed to a non-moving environment. I've used the mill to just get my heart rate up and get some sweat going but never really for any specific workload or goal. Just cruising and wishing I was outdoors. Today was different and kinda flew by. I was more focused on turnover and form and less about what song was on the pod. Maybe it's my lack of experience on the mill but I also get a sense of vertigo going during portions of most sessions and have a fear of real speeds that I'm capable of on the roads. It feels too fast! I saw some potential today though! Practice?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Matt ... funny you use the word steady. I saw it referenced in an article by Kevin Beck the other day. He describes his training lead up to Boston Marathon 2001 - and it has a lot of steady running. http://www.kemibe.com/baa2001.htm Take a look.

    I think we tend to think of what training we did in the last 3 months, or year even and see that as the key to a performance. There is certainly some significant truth in that, but it is also true that it is the what we did before that effects how we were able to train in those periods.

    In other words, maybe you are able to effectively do more steady runs this year because you did more slower - or MAF running last year.

    Or maybe not. But I think it is generally agreed, for success at distance running (with success being maximizing your potential) consistency is usually one of the most significant factors ... but it is consistency in what you did last week, the month before that, the quarter before that, the year before that - especially as the distance grows.

    I have wondered if I am training better this year because I am doing all these workouts and miles and I was not doing that last year. Or is it that I am just adding, building on top of that foundation, those layers, weeks of miles on mills, roads, and trails from last year that have led to being able to do what I am doing now - and by now, not just today's run but the ability to do today's run, this week's running, etc.

    Your long MAF running last year may have contributed to your skeletal and connective tissue strength to do runs now that are more challenging. Sure, maybe you could have done runs like this last year ... but could you have strung 3 days of them together without injury or sickness?

    Now mind you I don't know. I mean, you'd have to look at what you are doing on a big picture scale and say something like ... "okay so I did a 50 mile week last year but it was all at 9 min pace ...I am doing 45 this year but all at 8 min pace. Am I progressing?"

    I think I read some Couzens stuff that year over year you want to see increases in the load - with that being volume and intensity. We all generally agree that increasing both at the same time is a great way to get hurt. So we go back and forth ... MAF training, long runs, long weeks, long months, LSD ... and then we switch over to the neurostuff ... speed, repeats, intervals, tempo runs. Over time the amount of miles that are in the diet AND the velocity increase.

    So where are you?

    But ALL THAT SAID ... the biggest key is that you need to enjoy it and believe in it. You also said, I feel great afterwards. That tells me this - you are liking what you are doing. And that said you will want to run again. And that said, it means you will run more, which will contribute back to that overall consistency, self belief, examination. If you told me, "yeah I am doing this faster stuff, am out of breath and then I vomit and lay on the couch and hate it" then I think your approach would be short lived (although that is an addiction for some too)

    How's that for a non answer?

    ReplyDelete
  6. By the way, this is one of my favorite quick reads on endurance training ever ... http://www.kemibe.com/training.htm

    ReplyDelete
  7. JP - no doubt the biggest issue is the head in the treadmill. If one can make it a game, turn their head off, and not think about how stupid the whole activity is - then it can be a good tool to supplement training on days like today.

    I think the vertigo will pass. I use to get off the mill and have to immediately sit down because of that non motion to motion thing too but I think I am just used to it now. I have seen a lot of first time mill folks deal with that (like my wife) ... and just seems to pass.

    I get wrapped up in what mill speeds means to the outside. I did it in my last comment back to you but I need to keep reminding myself - mill speeds don't translate to road speeds. Mill speeds translate to mill speeds. So just compare them mill workout to mill workout ...

    ReplyDelete
  8. i would pay money to see your running 14 mph on the mill in a crowded work gym... can you get one of these workouts on youtube?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Your answer works for me, thanks. I think the consistency is huge. I'm justifying the uncomfortableness in a kind of anti-MAF way. One can't run too hard and keep running. If there's a program in place, expectation of a certain amount of running to be done, one probably isn't going to tempo Monday that wipes-out Tuesday, etc. So, as long as one is able to continue to hit the workouts w/quality then everything should be on track. And I think the running should just get easier or more comfortable at those speeds etc. That's kinda what MAF is all about. I'm just taking a drastically different approach this year. My MAF runs last year were DISCIPLINED. Now, I'm just running, but again there's an internal disciplinarian that suggests that's hard enough because you have to run 1:10 tomorrow, etc.

    Thanks for the feedback. I'll read those articles and stay consistent.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hey Crazy Treadmill Runner Dude-
    I stuck with running the MAF zones TO THE T but not with my Computrainer cycling. Tooo restrictive but it didn't seem to cause any negative results with the running.
    Happy winter. We are getting pummeled here in New England again with snow today

    ReplyDelete
  11. "I would pay money to see your running 14 mph on the mill in a crowded work gym... can you get one of these workouts on youtube?"

    HA HA HA HA! No crap, that would be hilarious to plant someone on the other side with a small camera to pan around...

    ReplyDelete
  12. George,

    I just got a Garmin with HR monitor and am now trying to keep my easy days in zone 1. But I am honestly losing my mind because zone 1 is a snails pace. Up until now, I must have been running in zone 2 for my easy runs.

    The things I've read on this kind of training, though, say that everyone thinks the same thing ("I can't keep running this slow!"). I'm wondering what you think about this.

    Do I stick to the plan and keep grinding out suuuuuper slow zone 1 runs, or do I drop this plan and go back to my own plan of just running.

    I've noticed lately you say you're trying to keep your easy days really easy, as well, which is why I figure I'd see what you think.

    Basically, can I get faster running so slow? I've been under the impression that the only way you get faster is by running faster.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Pretty funny George. I used to go to 24 Hour Fitness, every once in awhile I would crank it to 5:00 pace for less than a minute and everyone would look at me like I was a Handytard.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Okay - I think I can coordinate with Phil (prmazza.blogspot.com) a video shoot of the mill. I might need a body double though for the crash scenes. Any suggestions?

    ReplyDelete
  15. Skatona ...

    Your question is not easy - and in fact has been the source of contention amongst some of us in the "blogosphere."

    There is a body of folks who subscribe to what is called MAF training who would say - yes, you get faster by going slower. Perhaps the greatest known case of this is with tri legend Mark Allen who would do whole segments of his training at MAF (or below).

    The general thought here is that you get more efficient at the same HR and hence run faster at that same HR over time. According to Noakes' write up on Mr. Allen in the Lore of Running, Mark was able to maintain a MAF HR of 150 (ish) at 5:20 pace!

    This has been questioned by some because if Mark was able to maintain such a pace at MAF, he'd run a 2:20 marathon. As I understand it, there are some who question if he held these paces given his best marathon was a 2:18.

    In any case, it does not matter: Mark won six Ironman championships, including one at the age of 37. There has to be some merit to his training, and that training included whole segments where his HR remained "MAF"-esque or easy.

    Additionally, I have spoke with at least tri guy I respect who believes that MAF is a great starting point for all, but much more applicable for the IM - where one will need to tap into fat stores (as they will be out there for 8-15 hours) - which MAF training teaches your systems to do. The IM is truly the endurance event of endurance events ... it is not about speed as I have heard those folks say.

    More to the root of your question - can you get faster by running easy. The short answer is yes. The longer answer assumes the following:
    1.) consistency in training
    2.) more running (meaning greater volume).
    In other words, if your typical volume is 20 miles a week, just running all of that easy is not going to get you any gain. You are going to need to up the volume with the easier miles to begin to recognize benefit.

    Now, I will shift my answer: will you get as fast as you can be with just easy running? No. While easy training will help you get faster by making you build up the muscular and connective tissue to be stronger, better your running economy, build capillary beds, help you loose weight, etc - it prepares you for faster running. It is building that base or foundation that you can then lean on with faster running.

    Because ultimately, the only way to run faster is to run faster.

    So, there is generally agreement that training needs to use an aerobic component (easy running, low HR running) and a faster one (neuromuscular component). The challenge is determining how much, when, what the mix is ... based on your strengths, weaknesses, goals, times available ... and then consistently and appropriately tweaking that training approach (when necessary) to assure maximum benefit.

    Side note ... there appears to also be some supporting research that a down period of easy running is recommended for most folks at some point during the year. From what I understand, this is to allow muscle recuperation as well as adrenal gland (flight or fight) stimulus to subside for a bit. I really don't know about this ... for every person I see successful with that, I can name people (particularly masters runners) who seem to be tagging it 12 months out of the year (Bernie B is the prime example).

    So in Matt's case, he built a base last year and is doing some harder stuff now. Is that right or wrong? I don't know. What do I know? I have only talked to Matt via a blog. Matt knows. Or at least Matt is in the best position to know. He is in the best position to look at his training holistically and say what is working, what is not, what training gets him jazzed but leaves him ready for the next workout.

    And that is probably true for you too.

    Again, I feel like I wrote a lot here but gave you a non answer. Or an answer that I hear too often that I don't like - "it depends." But I think it is an honest answer.

    Here is a question for you - how are you testing your progress? Are you seeing demonstrable progress that you are getting better with zone 1 running?

    Last thought for now ... basically, the development of the aerobic system is thought to be limitless. Build that big base with more miles, more easy miles, enjoy your time out there. The bigger your aerobic engine, the more you will be able to get after it anaerobically. But don't be afraid to put the HR monitor down and be the caveman and chase your prey until you feel like your head is going to explode.

    For 20 minutes at least twice a week that is.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Yeah, you definitely need to video a full mile attempt.

    Load up some pillows and cushions behind the mill, get some music blaring, occassionally let a primal yell to pump yourself up and see how long you can last. Get in trouble, just jump off the back.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Wow, thanks for the lengthy reply.

    As for measuring my success with zone 1 running: it's too soon to say. I've only just got my HR monitor (last friday), so have only just started this plan. After a month I'll have to take a look at the hr:speed ratio and see if there's any improvement. Fingers crossed.

    Thanks again, that was helpful.

    ReplyDelete